China-Related Commercial Disputes: Litigation, Arbitration and Enforcement
Disputes in the AI supply chain look familiar: late delivery, quality failures, unpaid invoices, misappropriated designs, deadlocked joint ventures, terminated distributors. What changes the outcome is the forum. A clause drafted for a European counterparty can be close to unenforceable in China, or enforceable only after a costly detour through recognition proceedings.
The work therefore starts before the dispute — with the clause — and continues through evidence, preservation, judgment or award, and enforcement. This page sets out how each stage works in practice.
The disputes we see most
Supply and quality. Goods that fail acceptance, components that fail in the field, and warranty claims that the supplier disputes on the basis of an unstated specification.
Payment. Unpaid invoices, set-off claims, and retention withheld against a disputed defect.
IP misappropriation. Designs disclosed to a supplier and appearing in a competitor’s product; firmware copied; model parameters taken by a departing engineer.
Joint venture deadlock. Disagreement over capital calls, related-party transactions, board appointments or the transfer of technology to a JV subsidiary.
Distribution termination. A distributor terminated for missed targets, or a supplier terminated without notice, with inventory and warranty obligations left unresolved.
Employment and trade secrets. Senior engineers leaving with know-how, and the enforceability of non-compete and confidentiality obligations.
Choosing the forum before the dispute
| Forum | Enforceability in China | Typical duration | When it is the right choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chinese court, first instance | Direct | 6–12 months, plus appeal | Chinese assets, Chinese defendant, need for preservation |
| CIETAC, BAC, SHAC, SCIA (mainland seat) | Direct | 6–12 months to award | Confidentiality, technical expertise, Chinese enforcement |
| HKIAC, SIAC (foreign seat) | Under the New York Convention | 9–18 months | Neutral seat, international counterparty, multi-jurisdiction assets |
| Foreign court | Generally not enforceable | — | Only where assets are outside China |
The clause should be drafted with the defendant’s assets in mind. A neutral seat is worth little if the only asset is a factory in Jiangsu and the award must be recognised there anyway; a Chinese seat is worth little if the counterparty holds assets in three other jurisdictions.
Evidence and preservation
Chinese civil procedure is document-driven, and the party that can produce originals usually wins the factual argument. Contracts, purchase orders, delivery notes, inspection reports, payment records and correspondence should be preserved in their native form from the first sign of trouble.
Documents executed abroad generally require notarisation, and legalisation or an apostille depending on the country. Electronic evidence is admissible, but its authenticity must be demonstrable; screenshots alone are weak, while preserved devices, system logs and hash values are strong.
Two preservation tools matter more than any other procedural step. Property preservation freezes assets and is available in support of litigation and mainland-seated arbitration, subject to an application and usually security. Behaviour preservation can restrain an ongoing infringement, and in IP cases it is often the only remedy that arrives in time to matter.
Enforcement
A Chinese court judgment is enforced through the court’s enforcement division, which can freeze and sell assets, restrict high spending and, in serious cases, impose credit restrictions on the legal representative.
A mainland-seated arbitral award is enforced through the same courts, with limited grounds for refusal. A foreign-seated award is enforced under the New York Convention, to which China has been a party since 1987, subject to commercial and reciprocity reservations.
Foreign court judgments remain difficult. Enforcement depends on bilateral treaties or reciprocity, and the practical scope is narrow; the 2024 arrangement with Hong Kong provides a workable route for Hong Kong judgments. For most foreign parties, this asymmetry is the reason arbitration is chosen in the first place.
The criminal lever
Serious trade secret cases can be pursued criminally as well as civilly, and a criminal complaint changes the negotiating position because it reaches the individuals, not only the company. It requires proof of secrecy measures, commercial value and loss, and it should be used where the evidence supports it. A complaint that fails can damage both the civil case and any prospect of settlement.
What we do
- Dispute assessment: merits, recovery prospects, cost and timeline before proceedings
- Forum and clause review, including for contracts not yet signed
- Pre-litigation strategy: demand letters, settlement architecture, preservation timing
- Litigation and arbitration in Chinese courts and arbitral institutions
- Evidence preparation, notarisation and expert appraisal coordination
- Asset tracing and preservation applications
- Enforcement of judgments and awards, including cross-border recognition
- Trade secret and IP disputes, civil and criminal
In-depth guides
- Arbitration or Chinese Courts? Drafting the Dispute Clause
- Enforcing a Foreign Arbitral Award in China
- Freezing Assets Before Judgment: Property Preservation in China
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
Should a contract with a Chinese counterparty provide for arbitration or Chinese courts? It depends on what you need to enforce. China-seated arbitration and Chinese court judgments are enforceable in China; foreign court judgments generally are not. Foreign-seated awards are enforceable under the New York Convention, which makes a well-chosen seat the most reliable cross-border option.
Can we enforce a foreign court judgment in China? Only in limited circumstances — bilateral treaties or reciprocity, with a narrow practical scope. The 2024 arrangement with Hong Kong provides a workable route for Hong Kong judgments.
How long does commercial litigation in China take? A first-instance commercial case commonly takes six to twelve months, with appeal adding six to nine. Preservation, appraisal and service difficulties extend this.
Can we freeze the counterparty’s assets before judgment? Yes. Property preservation is available in support of litigation and mainland-seated arbitration, subject to an application, usually security, and a court decision. Timing is decisive.
What evidence do Chinese courts expect? Written contracts, invoices, delivery receipts, payment records and correspondence, with originals available. Foreign documents usually need notarisation and legalisation or an apostille. Electronic evidence must be provably authentic.
Is a criminal complaint a legitimate tool in a trade secret dispute? It can be, where the evidence supports secrecy measures, commercial value and loss. It should not be used as pressure; a failed complaint can damage the civil case.
How enforceable is a settlement agreement? A settlement confirmed by a court or tribunal is enforceable as such; a private settlement must be sued on if breached. Where payment is staged, security and an acceleration clause matter more than the promise.