Geason Law Offices · Free Resource
China Cross-Border Data Transfer Decision Tree
Which of the three legal pathways applies to your data transfer? Answer these questions to find out.
The Three Pathways at a Glance
Path 1 · Most rigorous
Security Assessment
For large volumes or important data. Reviewed by the CAC.
- Timeline: 3–6 months
- Validity: 3 years
- Level of scrutiny: High
Path 2 · Most common
Standard Contract
For most personal information transfers below the threshold.
- Timeline: 20–40 working days
- Validity: Until material change
- Level of scrutiny: Moderate
Path 3 · Newer option
Certification
For companies with multiple ongoing transfers.
- Timeline: 2–4 months
- Validity: 3 years (annual audit)
- Level of scrutiny: Moderate-high
Decision Tree
Step 1: Are you a Critical Information Infrastructure (CII) operator?
CII operators are entities in key sectors (energy, transport, finance, telecom, etc.) whose systems, if damaged, could seriously harm national security, public interest, or people's well-being. Most tech startups are NOT CII operators.
Yes
→ Security Assessment required. You must go through the CAC security assessment pathway for any cross-border transfer of personal information or important data.
Step 2: Are you transferring "important data" (重要数据) out of China?
Important data is data that, if leaked, tampered with, or destroyed, could endanger national security, economic operation, public health, or public security. The definition is sector-specific. Most general business data is not "important data."
Yes
→ Security Assessment required. Any cross-border transfer of important data must go through the security assessment pathway.
No / Not sure
→ Continue to Step 3.
Step 3: Are you transferring personal information of Chinese individuals?
Personal information includes any data that can identify a living individual — names, contact details, IDs, location data, browsing behaviour, etc. If your product has Chinese users, you almost certainly handle personal information.
No
→ If you are only transferring general business data (not personal information, not important data), and you are not a CII operator, no special cross-border transfer procedure is required. But you should still document the transfer and ensure compliance with general data security obligations.
Step 4: How much personal information are you transferring?
The thresholds that trigger the security assessment pathway are:
- 1,000,000+ individuals (personal information) → Security Assessment
- 10,000+ individuals (sensitive personal information) → Security Assessment
- Below these thresholds → Standard Contract or Certification
Above thresholds
→ Security Assessment required. You must apply through the local CAC for a security assessment.
Below thresholds
→ Continue to Step 5.
Step 5: Standard Contract or Certification?
If you are below the security assessment thresholds, you can choose between the standard contract pathway and the certification pathway.
Standard Contract
→ Choose this if you have a single or limited number of data transfer streams, and you want the simplest, most established pathway. Sign the CAC standard contract template with the overseas recipient, complete a PIA, and file with the local CAC.
Certification
→ Choose this if you have multiple, ongoing data transfer streams and want a single approval covering all of them. Certification must be obtained from an accredited certification body. Requires annual surveillance audits.
Pathway Comparison
| Factor | Security Assessment | Standard Contract | Certification |
| Trigger | CII operator, important data, or large PI volume | PI below threshold | PI below threshold, multiple streams |
| Authority | CAC (national) | Local CAC | Accredited certification body |
| Timeline | 3–6 months | 20–40 working days (filing) | 2–4 months |
| Validity | 3 years | Until material change | 3 years (annual audit) |
| Complexity | High — detailed application and review | Moderate — standard template + PIA | Moderate-high — full management system review |
| Cost | Higher | Lower | Medium |
Important caveats:
- This decision tree is a simplified overview. Real-world situations are often more complex — especially for AI companies with training data, model weights, and global infrastructure.
- AI-specific considerations: Transfer of training data, model weights, and AI-generated outputs each have their own nuances that may affect which pathway applies.
- Rules are evolving. China's cross-border data transfer framework continues to develop with new guidelines and interpretations.
- This resource is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For a proper assessment of your specific data transfer situation, contact Geason Law Offices.
Want more resources like this?
Get monthly updates on China AI regulation, new compliance guides, and practical tools — straight to your inbox.
One email per month. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.