Key Takeaways
- ESG is no longer optional. Customers, investors, and regulators increasingly demand sustainable supply chains.
- China is serious about decarbonization. The double carbon goal is driving real change in manufacturing.
- Environmental risk is supply chain risk. Factory shutdowns and energy rationing can disrupt production.
- Start with measurement. You cannot manage what you do not measure — calculate your carbon footprint first.
- Work with factories, not against them. Most factories want to improve but need support and investment.
- Certifications are a starting point. ISO 14001 is good, but look for evidence of actual implementation.
1. Introduction: ESG Comes to Chinese Manufacturing
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations have moved from the periphery to the center of global supply chain management. For foreign hardware companies sourcing from China, sustainability is no longer just a “nice to have” — it is a business imperative driven by customer demands, investor pressure, regulatory requirements, and supply chain risk.
China, as the world’s factory, is both a major source of emissions and a critical player in the global transition to sustainability. The Chinese government’s “double carbon” goal — peak carbon by 2030, carbon neutrality by 2060 — is driving sweeping changes in manufacturing, from stricter environmental enforcement to incentives for green technology adoption.
For foreign companies manufacturing in China, this creates both challenges and opportunities. On one hand, environmental regulations can lead to factory shutdowns, production restrictions, and cost increases. On the other hand, companies that build sustainable supply chains can differentiate themselves, reduce long-term costs, and future-proof their business.
He Qianggao, a senior lawyer at Geason Law Offices with over 10 years of experience advising foreign companies on Chinese manufacturing and compliance (license 14403201310092337), has observed the shift firsthand: “Five years ago, clients rarely asked about environmental or sustainability issues in their supply chain. Now it comes up in almost every manufacturing engagement. The driver is not just regulation — it is customer demand. Companies whose customers are in Europe or North America are under pressure to show they have sustainable supply chains, or they lose business.”
This guide explores ESG and sustainable manufacturing in China. It covers the policy landscape, environmental risks in the supply chain, how to assess factory sustainability performance, carbon footprint measurement, green manufacturing practices, and how to build more sustainable supply chains.
2. China’s Environmental Policy Landscape
2.1 The Double Carbon Goal
In September 2020, China announced its “double carbon” (双碳) goal:
- Carbon peak by 2030: China’s carbon dioxide emissions will reach their peak no later than 2030.
- Carbon neutrality by 2060: China will achieve carbon neutrality (net-zero emissions) by 2060.
This is one of the most ambitious climate commitments in the world, and it is driving policy changes across the economy, including manufacturing.
2.2 Key Environmental Policies Affecting Manufacturing
| Policy | What It Does | Impact on Manufacturing |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental Protection Law (2015) | Strengthened environmental enforcement, increased penalties | Factories face steeper fines for violations |
| Environmental Protection Tax (2018) | Tax on pollution (air, water, solid waste, noise) | Polluting factories pay more; incentives to reduce emissions |
| Carbon Trading Scheme (2021) | National emissions trading system for power generation, expanding to industry | Creates market-based incentive for emission reduction |
| “Double Control” of Energy (能耗双控) | Controls both total energy consumption and energy intensity | High-energy factories face production limits or shutdowns |
| Green Factory Program | Certifies “green factories” that meet eco-friendly criteria | Certified factories get incentives and better access to resources |
| Pollution Discharge Permits | All factories need permits specifying allowed discharge levels | Factories operating without permits face closure |
| Circular Economy Promotion Law | Promotes resource recycling and waste reduction | Encourages material efficiency and recycling |
2.3 Enforcement: “Environmental Protection Storms”
China has periodic “environmental protection storms” (环保风暴) — intensive enforcement campaigns where inspectors fan out across the country, shutting down non-compliant factories. These campaigns are unpredictable and can cause sudden supply disruptions.
During these campaigns:
- Factories without proper permits are shut down
- Factories exceeding emission limits are fined or ordered to stop production
- High-polluting industries (plating, painting, casting, etc.) are hit hardest
- Even compliant factories may face temporary production restrictions
- Smaller, less sophisticated factories are most at risk
The frequency and intensity of these campaigns have increased over the years. For foreign buyers, this means environmental compliance in your supply chain is not just an ethical issue — it is a supply continuity issue.
3. Environmental Risks in the Manufacturing Supply Chain
3.1 Factory Shutdown Risk
The most immediate risk is that your factory could be shut down — temporarily or permanently — due to environmental violations. This can happen with little warning, especially during enforcement campaigns.
High-risk industries:
- Electroplating and metal finishing
- Painting and coating
- Casting and foundry
- Battery manufacturing
- Chemical processing
- Textile dyeing
- Plastic recycling
How to mitigate:
- Verify the factory has all required environmental permits
- Check for past environmental violations
- Maintain backup suppliers for high-risk products
- Include business continuity provisions in contracts
3.2 Energy Rationing Risk
China’s “double control” policy on energy consumption can lead to power rationing for factories. During periods of tight energy supply, high-energy-consuming factories may face:
- Reduced operating hours (e.g., only 3-4 days per week)
- Production caps or quotas
- Rolling blackouts
- Higher electricity prices during peak hours
This has happened several times in recent years in various provinces, causing production delays and delivery disruptions.
3.3 Cost Increase Risk
Environmental compliance costs money. As regulations tighten, factories face:
- Higher energy costs (carbon pricing, energy efficiency requirements)
- Pollution discharge fees and environmental taxes
- Investment in pollution control equipment
- Waste treatment and disposal costs
- Certification and audit costs
These costs get passed on to buyers in the form of higher prices. The question is not whether environmental costs will increase — they will — but by how much and how fast.
3.4 Regulatory and Legal Risk
Environmental non-compliance exposes factories (and potentially their customers) to legal risks:
- Fines and penalties
- Production suspension or closure orders
- Criminal liability for serious violations
- Civil lawsuits from affected parties
- Reputational damage
For foreign buyers, while you may not be directly liable for your factory’s environmental violations under Chinese law, you can be affected indirectly through supply disruptions and brand damage.
4. Assessing Factory Environmental Performance
4.1 Environmental Certifications
Certifications are a starting point for assessing a factory’s environmental performance:
ISO 14001 — Environmental Management System:
- The most common environmental certification
- Indicates the factory has a documented environmental management system
- Requires commitment to compliance and continuous improvement
- Implementation quality varies (as with ISO 9001)
- Baseline certification — necessary but not sufficient
ISO 50001 — Energy Management System:
- Focuses specifically on energy efficiency
- Indicates the factory has systems to manage and reduce energy use
- Less common than ISO 14001 but more relevant for carbon reduction
- Good indicator of a factory that takes sustainability seriously
ISO 14064 — Greenhouse Gas Accounting:
- Specifies requirements for quantifying and reporting GHG emissions
- ISO 14064-1: organizational-level GHG inventory
- ISO 14064-3: GHG assertion verification
- Indicates the factory is measuring its carbon footprint
Green Factory (绿色工厂) Certification:
- Chinese government certification at provincial or national level
- Evaluates factories on: management system, energy use, resource use, environmental performance, product design
- Certified factories get policy incentives
- Good indicator of above-average environmental performance
4.2 Environmental Audit Checklist
Beyond certifications, conduct a thorough environmental audit:
Permits and compliance:
- Environmental impact assessment (EIA) approval — does the factory have EIA approval for its actual production processes?
- Pollution discharge permit (排污许可证) — is it valid? Does it cover all emissions?
- Business license — does the business scope match actual operations?
- Any history of environmental penalties or violations?
Pollution control:
- Air pollution control equipment (dust collectors, VOC treatment, etc.) — present and functioning?
- Wastewater treatment system — does the factory treat its own wastewater, or is it treated at a municipal plant?
- Solid waste management — proper storage, classification, disposal?
- Hazardous waste management — licensed disposal contractor? Proper storage and labeling?
Energy and resources:
- Energy consumption per unit of output — trend over time?
- Energy sources — coal, natural gas, electricity, renewables?
- Water consumption and recycling rate
- Material efficiency — scrap rates, material utilization
Management systems:
- Environmental management system — documented, implemented, audited?
- Emergency response plans — for spills, leaks, accidents?
- Employee training — environmental and safety training?
- Monitoring and reporting — emission monitoring, energy tracking?
4.3 How to Check for Environmental Violations
You can check a factory’s environmental compliance record through Chinese government databases:
- Local Ecology and Environment Bureau (生态环境局) websites — publish environmental penalties
- National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System (gsxt.gov.cn) — lists administrative penalties
- Environmental protection hotline (12369) — complaint records
- Provincial-level environmental information disclosure platforms
Note: These databases are in Chinese. You may need assistance from a Chinese speaker or a professional due diligence firm.
5. Carbon Footprint Measurement
5.1 Why Measure Your Product Carbon Footprint?
- Customer demand. More and more customers (especially in Europe) require carbon footprint data from suppliers.
- Regulatory requirements. The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and similar regulations will require carbon reporting for imported goods.
- Cost reduction. Measuring emissions reveals opportunities to reduce energy and material use, saving money.
- Competitive advantage. Companies that can show low-carbon products gain market share.
- Investor pressure. Investors increasingly ask for ESG data, including supply chain emissions.
5.2 Carbon Footprint Basics
Scopes of emissions (GHG Protocol):
- Scope 1: Direct emissions from owned or controlled sources (e.g., factory boilers, vehicles)
- Scope 2: Indirect emissions from purchased energy (e.g., electricity, steam)
- Scope 3: All other indirect emissions in the value chain (e.g., raw material production, transport, product use, end-of-life)
For a product manufactured in China, Scope 3 (especially raw materials and purchased components) is often the largest part of the carbon footprint — typically 60-90% of total.
Product carbon footprint standards:
- ISO 14067: Greenhouse gases — Carbon footprint of products
- PAS 2050: Specification for the assessment of the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of goods and services
- GHG Protocol Product Standard: From WRI and WBCSD
5.3 How to Calculate Your Product’s Carbon Footprint
- Define scope and boundaries. Cradle-to-gate (raw materials to factory gate) or cradle-to-grave (full lifecycle)?
- Create a bill of materials (BOM). List all materials and components with quantities.
- Collect data from your factory. Energy use per unit, process emissions, waste.
- Collect supplier data. Material production emissions from key suppliers.
- Use emission factors. If primary data is not available, use database emission factors (IPCC, ecoinvent, Chinese national databases).
- Calculate. Sum up all emissions by life cycle stage.
- Verify. Get third-party verification for credibility.
5.4 Challenges with Chinese Supply Chains
- Data availability. Many Chinese factories do not track detailed emissions data.
- Supplier data gap. Getting emissions data from sub-suppliers (component makers, material suppliers) is difficult.
- Data quality. When data is available, it may not be accurate or verified.
- Complex supply chains. Chinese manufacturing supply chains are deep and multi-layered, making tracing difficult.
Practical approach: Start with the big items. Focus on the top 5-10 components and processes that contribute most to your product’s weight or value. Use average emission factors for the rest. You can refine over time.
6. Green Manufacturing Practices in China
Chinese factories are adopting green manufacturing practices, driven by regulation, cost savings, and customer demand. Here are some of the most common:
6.1 Energy Efficiency
- LED lighting upgrades. Replacing traditional lighting with LED reduces lighting energy use by 50-70%.
- Energy-efficient motors and equipment. High-efficiency motors, variable frequency drives (VFDs), and energy-saving production equipment.
- Process optimization. Optimizing production processes to reduce energy consumption per unit.
- Waste heat recovery. Capturing and reusing waste heat from production processes.
- Building insulation and HVAC optimization. Reducing heating and cooling needs.
6.2 Renewable Energy
- Solar PV installations. Many factories install rooftop solar panels to generate their own electricity.
- Purchased renewable energy. Buying renewable energy certificates (RECs) or green electricity from the grid.
- Wind power. Some factories in windy regions invest in wind power.
China has become the world’s largest market for solar PV, and factory rooftop solar is growing rapidly.
6.3 Material Efficiency and Circular Economy
- Scrap reduction and recycling. Reducing material waste in production, recycling scrap material.
- Design for recyclability. Designing products for easier disassembly and material recovery.
- Closed-loop manufacturing. Using recycled materials in production, recycling production waste back into the process.
- Packaging reduction. Reducing packaging material use, using recycled or recyclable packaging.
6.4 Pollution Prevention
- Cleaner production technologies. Replacing polluting processes with cleaner alternatives.
- VOC reduction. For painting and coating processes, using low-VOC materials and improving capture and treatment.
- Wastewater treatment and reuse. Treating wastewater and reusing it in production.
- Hazardous waste reduction. Reducing use of hazardous materials, proper treatment and disposal.
7. Building a Sustainable Supply Chain in China
7.1 Getting Started
If you are new to supply chain sustainability, here is how to start:
- Assess your current state. What do you know about your suppliers’ environmental performance? What are the biggest risks?
- Set priorities. Focus on the areas that matter most: high-risk suppliers, high-impact products, customer requirements.
- Start measuring. Calculate your product carbon footprint, even at a high level. You cannot manage what you do not measure.
- Engage your suppliers. Talk to your factories about sustainability. Understand their capabilities and challenges.
- Set targets. Define specific, measurable sustainability goals and timelines.
7.2 Supplier Engagement Strategies
Start with your largest suppliers. They have the biggest impact and often the most resources to invest in improvements.
Be collaborative, not punitive. Approach sustainability as a joint challenge:
- Share your sustainability goals and why they matter
- Ask factories about their own sustainability efforts and challenges
- Offer support: technical assistance, training, longer-term contracts, or price adjustments
- Set improvement targets together
- Recognize and reward progress
Provide incentives for improvement:
- Longer-term contracts for factories that meet sustainability targets
- Price premiums for verified low-carbon or eco-friendly production
- Priority status for new product introductions
- Public recognition (with permission)
7.3 Supply Chain Transparency
Transparency is the foundation of sustainable supply chains:
- Map your supply chain. Know who your suppliers are, including sub-suppliers for critical components.
- Collect data regularly. Establish regular reporting on environmental metrics (energy use, emissions, waste).
- Use digital tools. Supply chain management software, sustainability platforms, and blockchain for traceability.
- Third-party verification. For key suppliers, use third-party audits to verify data.
7.4 Low-Carbon Product Development
The biggest opportunity to reduce product carbon footprint is during product design:
- Material selection. Choose materials with lower embodied carbon.
- Design for recyclability. Make products easier to disassemble and recycle.
- Lightweighting. Reduce material use while maintaining performance.
- Energy efficiency in use. For electronic products, reduce power consumption.
- Modular design. Allow repair and upgrade, extending product life.
8. Legal and Contractual Considerations
8.1 Environmental Clauses in Manufacturing Contracts
Include environmental and sustainability provisions in your manufacturing agreements:
- Compliance with laws. Supplier warrants compliance with all applicable environmental laws and regulations.
- Environmental permits. Supplier shall maintain all required environmental permits.
- Right to audit. Buyer has the right to conduct environmental audits of the supplier’s facilities.
- Information sharing. Supplier shall provide environmental data and sustainability information upon request.
- Continuous improvement. Agreed environmental improvement targets and timelines.
- Remediation. If non-compliance is found, supplier must implement corrective actions within agreed timeframe.
- Termination. Right to terminate for serious or repeated environmental violations.
8.2 Carbon and ESG Regulations Affecting Imports
Foreign companies importing from China need to be aware of emerging regulations in their target markets:
EU CBAM (Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism):
- Carbon border tax on imported goods from high-emission countries
- Initially covers steel, aluminum, cement, fertilizers, electricity, hydrogen
- Expanding to more sectors over time
- Importers must report embedded emissions and purchase CBAM certificates
EU CSRD (Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive):
- Requires large companies to report on sustainability, including supply chain impacts
- Applies to companies operating in the EU with significant revenue
- Requires third-party assurance of sustainability information
US and other markets:
- Various state-level and federal ESG disclosure proposals
- SEC climate disclosure rules (development ongoing)
- Import restrictions on products made with forced labor (e.g., Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act)
These regulations mean foreign companies need visibility into their Chinese supply chains’ environmental and social performance — even if the Chinese factories themselves are not directly subject to the rules.
9. Key Takeaways
ESG and sustainable manufacturing are transforming Chinese supply chains. What was once a niche concern is now a mainstream business issue driven by regulation, customer demand, and investor pressure. For foreign hardware companies sourcing from China, building sustainable supply chains is both a responsibility and a competitive advantage.
Core principles:
- China’s double carbon goal is real. Environmental enforcement and decarbonization will only intensify.
- Environmental risk is supply chain risk. Factory shutdowns, energy rationing, and cost increases can disrupt your business.
- Start with measurement. Calculate your carbon footprint and understand your impact.
- Certifications are a starting point. ISO 14001 and others indicate capability — verify actual performance.
- Collaborate with suppliers. Factories want to improve but need support and incentives.
- Design for sustainability. The biggest carbon savings come from product design decisions.
- Stay ahead of regulation. Rules like CBAM and CSRD are changing import requirements.
At Geason Law Offices, we help foreign companies navigate the legal and regulatory landscape of sustainable manufacturing in China. From environmental compliance and contract provisions to supply chain ESG assessments and regulatory advice, He Qianggao and our team bring over a decade of experience to help you build sustainable, resilient supply chains.
FAQ
Q1: What quality control standards apply to manufactured goods in China?
A1: China has a comprehensive system of quality standards including national standards (GB), industry standards, local standards, and enterprise standards. For many consumer products, compliance with GB standards is mandatory. Products sold in China may also require CCC (China Compulsory Certification) marking depending on the product category. For export products, manufacturers must meet the standards of the destination country. China’s Product Quality Law establishes manufacturer liability for defective products, including compensation for damages caused by quality issues.
Q2: What are the key labor law requirements for manufacturing facilities in China?
A2: Manufacturing facilities in China must comply with comprehensive labor requirements including standard working hours (40 hours/week), overtime pay (150% on weekdays, 200% on rest days, 300% on statutory holidays), mandatory social insurance contributions (pension, medical, unemployment, work injury, maternity), written employment contracts within 30 days of hiring, and workplace safety standards under the Work Safety Law. For factories using dispatch workers, the total proportion of dispatched workers cannot exceed 10% of the total workforce.
Q3: What is the difference between OEM and ODM arrangements in China?
A3: OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturing) involves a foreign brand providing product specifications and designs to a Chinese factory that manufactures according to those exact specifications. ODM (Original Design Manufacturing) involves the Chinese factory both designing and manufacturing the product, with the foreign brand typically putting its own label on the finished product. The key legal differences relate to intellectual property ownership, liability for design defects, and the degree of control the brand has over the manufacturing process and quality standards.
Q4: How does China’s environmental regulation affect manufacturing operations?
A4: China’s environmental regulations have become increasingly stringent, particularly under the Environmental Protection Law and the “Dual Carbon” goals. Manufacturing facilities must obtain environmental impact assessments (EIA) before construction, install pollution control equipment, meet emission standards, and participate in the emissions trading system for certain pollutants. Violation penalties have increased significantly and can include daily fines, production suspensions, and even criminal liability for serious environmental pollution incidents.
Q5: How do I protect my IP when manufacturing in China?
A5: Protecting IP in Chinese manufacturing requires a multi-layered approach: registering trademarks, patents, and copyrights in China (not just in your home country), executing comprehensive manufacturing agreements with clear IP ownership provisions and confidentiality clauses, implementing supply chain controls to prevent overproduction and gray market diversion, conducting regular factory audits, and registering IP with China Customs to prevent unauthorized exports. It’s also important to conduct thorough due diligence on manufacturing partners and to structure agreements with clear dispute resolution mechanisms, preferably with Chinese court jurisdiction or arbitration in China.
Further Reading
- Supply Chain Risk Management in China: A Guide for Hardware Startups — Risk management
- Labor Law & HR in Chinese Factories: What Foreign Companies Need to Know — Labor practices
- Supplier Due Diligence & Factory Vetting in China: A Deep Dive — Due diligence
- Product Compliance Standards: RoHS, REACH, FCC, CE, UL for China Manufacturing — Compliance standards
Next Steps
Whether you are starting your sustainability journey or looking to deepen your supply chain ESG program, understanding the Chinese landscape is critical. The pace of change is accelerating — companies that act now will be better positioned for the future.
Two service lines most relevant for ESG and sustainable manufacturing:
- Compliance Review & Risk Assessment — ESG and supply chain compliance
- Manufacturing Legal Support in China — Manufacturing legal services
To discuss ESG or sustainable manufacturing in your China supply chain, Contact Geason Law Offices. The initial consultation is free; the form prepares an email in your own mail application.
Related guides in this series
- Raw Material Sourcing in China: Managing Price Volatility and Supply Risks
- Multi-Supplier Strategy & Risk Diversification in China Manufacturing
- Quality Management Systems in China: ISO 9001, IATF 16949, QC080000
Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article
What is China's 'double carbon' goal and how does it affect manufacturing?
China's 'double carbon' goal (双碳目标) is to reach carbon peak by 2030 and carbon neutrality by 2060. For manufacturing, this means: stricter environmental regulations, higher energy efficiency requirements, phase-out of high-emission production processes, incentives for green technology adoption, carbon trading schemes, and pressure on high-energy-consuming industries. Factories that fail to meet environmental standards face fines, production restrictions, or forced closure. Foreign buyers sourcing from China need to be aware that their suppliers may face capacity constraints or cost increases due to these policies.
How can I measure the carbon footprint of my Chinese-manufactured product?
To measure product carbon footprint: (1) Define the scope — cradle-to-gate (raw materials to factory gate) or cradle-to-grave (full lifecycle), (2) Collect data from your factory — energy use, material consumption, waste generation, transport, (3) Collect data from key suppliers — material production emissions, (4) Use established methodologies like GHG Protocol Product Standard or ISO 14067, (5) Calculate emissions using emission factors (IPCC, national databases, or ecoinvent), (6) Get third-party verification for credibility. Many Chinese factories have some emissions data but may not have calculated product-level footprints — you may need to work with them or hire a consultant.
What environmental certifications should I look for in Chinese factories?
Key environmental certifications for Chinese factories: (1) ISO 14001 — Environmental Management System, the most common baseline, (2) ISO 50001 — Energy Management System, for energy efficiency, (3) ISO 14064 — Greenhouse Gas (GHG) accounting and verification, (4) Green Factory certification (绿色工厂) — Chinese government certification for eco-friendly factories, (5) Carbon footprint verification — per ISO 14067 or PAS 2050, (6) Industry-specific: bluesign for textiles, FSC for wood, RBA for electronics. ISO 14001 is the baseline; look for additional certifications for higher sustainability performance.
What are the biggest environmental risks in Chinese manufacturing supply chains?
The biggest environmental risks include: (1) Factory shutdowns due to environmental enforcement — China regularly shuts down non-compliant factories, especially during 'environmental protection storms', (2) Energy rationing — high-energy-consuming industries may face power cuts or production limits, (3) Hazardous substance management — improper handling of chemicals and hazardous waste, (4) Water pollution — discharge of untreated wastewater, (5) Air pollution — VOC emissions, dust, particulate matter, (6) Climate change risk — physical risks from extreme weather, transition risks from decarbonization policies. These risks can disrupt your supply chain and increase costs.
How do I conduct an environmental audit of a Chinese factory?
To conduct an environmental audit: (1) Review certifications — ISO 14001, energy management, waste permits, (2) Check regulatory records — look for environmental penalties or violations on local ecology and environment bureau websites, (3) On-site audit — inspect production processes, waste management, pollution control equipment, energy use, chemical storage, (4) Document review — environmental impact assessment (EIA), pollution discharge permit, waste disposal contracts, emission monitoring data, (5) Worker interviews — ask about environmental practices and safety, (6) Supply chain assessment — check if key suppliers have environmental issues too. For comprehensive audits, hire a professional environmental consulting firm.
What is the 'double control' of energy policy in China?
The 'double control' of energy (能耗双控) is a Chinese policy that controls both total energy consumption and energy intensity (energy use per unit of GDP). For manufacturing, this means high-energy-consuming industries may face power cuts, production limits, or restrictions on expanding capacity. The policy is enforced at the provincial and local levels, and factories that exceed their energy quotas can face shutdowns or fines. Foreign buyers sourcing from energy-intensive industries need to monitor this policy as it can disrupt production and increase costs.
How can foreign buyers help their Chinese suppliers improve sustainability?
Foreign buyers can help their Chinese suppliers improve sustainability by providing clear sustainability requirements and expectations upfront, investing in supplier development through training and technical support, offering longer-term contracts and volume commitments that give suppliers the security to invest in green upgrades, sharing best practices and technology, and recognising and rewarding improvement rather than just penalising non-compliance. Most Chinese factories want to improve their environmental performance but need support, investment, and clear incentives to do so.