Every contract manufacturing relationship requires disclosure. The factory cannot quote, build tooling or produce without drawings, specifications and often a physical sample. The question is not whether to disclose, but how much, in what form, to whom, and with what record.
Foreign companies that lose designs in China usually lose them in the same way: a complete drawing set sent early to obtain a competitive quotation, no marking, no distribution list, no acknowledgement, and no patent filed. By the time a copy appears in a competitor’s catalogue, the buyer has neither the evidence nor the registered right that would make a claim practical.
The remedies exist and they work, but each one depends on something done months earlier. A trade secret claim depends on measures taken before disclosure. A patent claim depends on a filing made before disclosure. A customs seizure depends on a recordal made after grant but before the shipment. A liquidated damages claim depends on a clause drafted when the relationship was still competitive. This article sets out a protection programme in the order the decisions arise, because the order is what determines whether the later options are open.
Before the first quotation
The cheapest protection is the one applied before the factory sees anything. Four steps are worth taking at quotation stage.
Split the disclosure. Send the information needed to quote, not the information needed to manufacture. A dimensional drawing with critical features removed, a functional description without tolerances, or a sample with the enclosure sealed is often enough for a credible quotation. Complete manufacturing files follow only after selection and signature.
The test is whether a competent factory could produce a competitive part from what it has been given. If it could, too much has been sent. Most quotations need geometry, material family, approximate mass, surface finish and volume. They do not need tolerances on internal features, the gate and cooling layout, the test specification, the approved vendor list or the firmware.
Mark everything. Confidentiality markings on drawings, files and samples, with the recipient’s name and the date. Unmarked information is harder to characterise as secret, and the absence of markings is the first thing a supplier’s lawyer will point to.
The mark should carry the recipient’s name, not the word “confidential” alone. A drawing marked “Confidential — issued to Ningbo Xinda Precision, 14 March 2026, not for reproduction” is evidence about a specific disclosure. A drawing marked “Confidential” is evidence of a habit.
Use a short, specific NDA. A five-page NDA copied from another deal is less useful than a two-page agreement that identifies the information, the permitted purpose, the permitted recipients, the duration and the return obligation. Where the supplier refuses to sign before quoting, that is information about the supplier.
Keep a disclosure record. A simple log of what was sent, to whom, on what date and in what form. In a trade secret case this log is often the difference between a claim and an assertion.
The log should be maintained centrally rather than by the engineer who sent the file. Its fields are unglamorous: date, recipient company, named individual, document identifier and revision, channel, purpose, and whether an acknowledgement was received. A log kept in a shared spreadsheet and updated within a day of each disclosure is sufficient. A log reconstructed from sent mail after the event is not.
The design-file handover protocol
Disclosure is not one event. It is a sequence of releases, each justified by the next decision the factory has to make. Treating it as a sequence rather than a single handover is the difference between a controlled relationship and an uncontrolled one.
| Stage | What is released | Format and control | Record created |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concept | Silhouette, use case, target cost, volume range | Image or PDF, no dimensions, marked and numbered | NDA plus receipt |
| Quotation | Outline dimensions, material family, mass, finish, critical features omitted | Flattened PDF, per-recipient watermark | Disclosure log entry, acknowledgement |
| Tooling | Full geometry, tolerance scheme, mould specification | Native CAD or STEP, encrypted transfer, named recipients | Tooling release note, individual undertakings |
| Production | Complete drawing set, BOM, test specification, golden sample, firmware binary | Controlled portal, revision-controlled | Full register, signed receipt per revision |
| Service | Spare parts list, diagnostics, firmware update package | Restricted distribution | Service agreement schedule |
Four controls apply at every stage.
Format. Flattened PDFs remove editable geometry but not the information on the page, and a determined factory can rebuild a model from dimensioned views. Native CAD is worse, because it carries feature history, parameter names and often the designer’s notes. STEP files carry geometry without history and are the usual compromise at tooling stage; the newer STEP variants can carry tolerance and material annotations, which brings them close to native CAD in usefulness. Withholding native files raises the cost of copying. It does not prevent it, and the programme should not assume otherwise.
Identity. Every document carries a unique identifier, a revision and the recipient’s name, applied as a visible watermark and, where the format allows, as metadata. Watermarking is not a security control. It is an attribution control, and attribution is what turns a copied drawing into evidence.
Channel. Files go through a controlled portal or an encrypted archive with a per-recipient password delivered by a different channel. They do not go through WeChat, WhatsApp or a personal email account. The reason is not technological: a portal produces a download log with a timestamp and a user identity, and a messaging app produces a screenshot.
Acknowledgement. Each release is acknowledged in writing by a named individual at the factory, listing the document identifiers received. A company-level acknowledgement is weaker than a list of individuals, because the question later is who saw the file.
The handover meeting deserves its own record. A short minute recording who attended, which revisions were issued, what was withheld and when the next release will occur converts an informal transfer into a documented one. Where a factory asks for a file that is not due until the next stage, the refusal should be recorded in the same minute, with the reason. The refusal is the best evidence that the staged release was a deliberate control rather than an accident of timing.
Revision control matters more than most buyers expect. Factories work from whatever file is open on the machine, and an old revision left in a shared folder will be used. Superseded revisions should be recalled in writing, and the register should show the recall. Where a change is made after tooling, the change notice should state whether the tooling is affected and whether the factory may modify the tool.
At the end of the relationship, the return obligation should be executed rather than assumed. A certificate listing the documents returned or destroyed, signed by a named officer, is worth having. Where the factory retains a copy for statutory or quality-record reasons, the retention should be identified and agreed in advance, with a destruction date.
Two categories are commonly released by accident. The cost breakdown, which reveals your margin and your supplier prices, and the failure analysis reports, which describe where the design is weak. Neither is needed by a factory to manufacture, and both are valuable to a competitor. The test fixture deserves the same caution: a fixture is a map of the design’s test points and therefore of its vulnerabilities, and a factory that holds one holds a substantial part of the know-how.
Firmware needs its own protocol. Ship a signed binary, keep the signing key inside the buyer’s organisation, and disable debug interfaces on production units. A factory that holds the signing key can build units that your own device management will accept as genuine, which converts a design leak into a counterfeit channel that is difficult to detect. Where the factory must program keys, use a secure element or a programming house that you control, and require a key-injection record per unit.
The manufacturing agreement
The agreement should grant a licence, not an assignment. The supplier needs the right to use the drawings and specifications to make goods for the buyer; it does not need ownership, and it does not need the right to make the same goods for anyone else.
| Term | What it should say |
|---|---|
| Licence scope | Use solely to manufacture goods for the buyer, in the quantities ordered |
| No sublicensing | No disclosure to subcontractors without written approval and a back-to-back NDA |
| No third-party sales | No sale of the product, or of goods materially derived from it, to any other customer |
| Improvements | Ownership of process improvements and who may use them outside the relationship |
| Tooling and files | Buyer owns drawings, tooling and specifications; return or destruction on termination |
| Residuals | No right to use residual knowledge for competing products |
| Audit | Right to inspect production areas and records relevant to the licensed use |
| Survival | Confidentiality and return obligations survive termination |
The sub-contracting clause deserves particular attention. Many Chinese factories are assemblers that outsource components to smaller workshops, and a design disclosed to the supplier may reach three other businesses within a week. Approval rights, a list of approved subcontractors and flow-down obligations are the practical controls.
Approval should be specific to a named subcontractor and a named process. A general right to subcontract “with the buyer’s consent” is usually exercised by email, and the email is lost. A schedule listing approved subcontractors, the processes they perform and the date of approval is enforceable and auditable, and it gives the buyer a contractual hook when an unlisted workshop appears in the supply chain.
Three further clauses carry weight in practice. A capacity and exclusivity clause prevents the factory from taking orders that compete for the same line during your peak season, which is often the commercial motive for a second shift. A notification clause requires the factory to tell you within a stated period of any inquiry for a similar product, any approach by a competitor and any regulatory inspection. And a records clause requires production records, material purchase records and machine logs to be kept for a stated period and made available on request, which is the clause that makes an investigation possible.
The audit right should be drafted to be usable. “The buyer may audit the supplier’s facilities on reasonable notice” is a start, but it does not answer whether the buyer may bring a technical expert, photograph the tooling, inspect machine logs or take samples. Spell those out. An audit clause that cannot be exercised without a further negotiation is a clause that will not be exercised at the moment it matters.
Mould and tooling control
A mould is the physical embodiment of the design, and it is usually the single most valuable item the buyer has at the factory. It is also the item over which the buyer has the least practical control, because it sits on the factory’s floor, is maintained by the factory’s staff, and is worth more to the factory in use than in storage.
Ownership should be stated, not assumed. Chinese law does not resolve the question through a single default rule that a foreign buyer can rely on, and courts look at the contract, at who paid and at the parties’ conduct. A clause that says the buyer owns the tooling, that the tooling is held in bailment for the buyer, and that the factory has no lien or right of retention over it is the starting point. A factory in possession has leverage that a clause alone does not remove, so the clause needs to be paired with a practical recovery plan.
The tooling register is the operational core. It should record, for each tool: the tool number, the part it makes, the cavity count, the steel specification, the machine compatibility, the location, the date of acceptance, the replacement cost, the insured value, the amortisation status and whether the buyer has paid for it in full. Where the tool was paid for through a per-unit amortisation, the register should show when title passed, because a factory that has not recovered its cost will argue that it retains an interest.
Identification is what makes later attribution possible. Engrave the tool number on the mould base and, where the geometry allows, on each cavity insert. Number the cavities and keep first-off samples from each, because a part in the market can then be traced to a specific tool and cavity. Photograph the tool at acceptance, including the engraving, and keep the photographs with the acceptance record. For high-value tools, an embedded tag or a discreet mark in a non-visible area of the part achieves the same result less visibly.
Control of use is a matter of contract and of verification. The agreement should prohibit use of the tooling for any product other than the buyer’s, prohibit movement off site without written approval, and require a movement log where movement is approved. Maintenance responsibility should be allocated, with records, because a tool that has been run beyond its design life produces parts that fail and a dispute about who pays. Where the factory modifies a tool to fix a moulding defect, the modification should be recorded and approved, because an unrecorded modification is often the first sign that the tool has been used for another customer’s part.
Verification is where most programmes are thin. Shot counters, machine hour records and maintenance logs are produced in the ordinary course and can be reconciled against the buyer’s orders. Where the tool is capable of a known cycle time, the machine hours attributable to the buyer’s orders can be estimated, and a large gap between estimated and recorded hours is a question worth asking. The reconciliation does not prove a second shift on its own. It tells you where to look.
Recovery at the end of the relationship should be planned before it is needed. Who pays freight, what condition the tool must be in, whether spare inserts and drawings travel with it, and how quickly it must be released are all negotiable at the start and contentious at the end. A tool that cannot be moved because a final invoice is disputed is a tool that is not protecting anything.
Second-tier tooling deserves the same treatment. Where a sub-supplier makes a component with its own tool, the buyer’s register should record that tool too, and the flow-down agreement should give the buyer the same rights. Most design leaks in a multi-tier supply chain start at the tier that nobody visited.
Trade secret measures that courts recognise
Chinese trade secret law protects technical and business information that is not public, has commercial value and is subject to corresponding confidentiality measures. The third element is where most foreign claims fail.
Measures that are recognised in practice include:
- Written confidentiality undertakings from the individuals who actually see the information, not only from the company
- Access controls: separate storage, restricted folders, named user accounts, and a list of who may open which file
- Physical controls for samples and tooling, including a signing-out record
- Marking of documents and files, consistently applied
- Exit procedures for the supplier’s staff who have seen the information
- A record of disclosures, including the date and the recipient
The standard is proportionality, not perfection. A company that marks its drawings, limits distribution and keeps a log is in a materially better position than one that does none of these things, even if both have signed the same NDA.
Two measures are often overlooked because they sit with the supplier rather than the buyer. The first is the supplier’s own internal access control: a factory that keeps the buyer’s drawings on a shared server open to the whole engineering team has not, in substance, restricted access, whatever the NDA says. The manufacturing agreement should require a named access list and a secure storage location, and the audit should check it. The second is the exit procedure for the supplier’s staff. An engineer who leaves the factory with a copy of the drawings is the most common leak path, and a clause requiring the supplier to notify the buyer of the departure of anyone with access gives the buyer a chance to act.
Filing order: register before you disclose
Where the design is patentable, the filing order matters more than the drafting. China is a first-to-file jurisdiction, and a supplier or an affiliated entity that files first creates a problem that is expensive to unwind even when the buyer’s entitlement is clear.
Three routes are relevant:
- Invention patents for technical solutions with substantive novelty, examined and slower.
- Utility models for mechanical structures, registered with formal examination and available quickly, which suits product features with a short commercial cycle.
- Design patents for appearance, now protectable for fifteen years following the 2020 amendment.
For most hardware products, a combination is appropriate: utility models on the mechanical features, design patents on the appearance, invention patents on the core technology, and trademarks on the brand. Filing before disclosure also protects against the supplier’s own filing and gives the buyer a registered right to assert at customs.
The practical sequence is to file the applications that can be filed quickly before the tooling release, and to keep the invention patent applications for the core technology on a parallel track. A utility model filed on the day before tooling release costs little and closes the window in which a supplier could file on the same structure. An invention patent filed later, after the product has been sold, may still be available, but novelty depends on what was disclosed and when, and the analysis becomes contested.
Detection
Infringement is usually discovered in the market rather than in the factory. Three channels are worth maintaining: monitoring of Chinese e-commerce platforms and the supplier’s own catalogue, trade fair attendance, and customs data where available.
Attribution matters. Serial numbers, unique internal components, firmware identifiers and tooling marks allow a buyer to connect a product in the market to a specific factory and production run. Without attribution, a claim is difficult even where copying is obvious.
Customs recordal of patents, trademarks and copyrights allows the buyer to request border seizure of infringing exports, which is often the fastest way to interrupt a competing shipment.
The monitoring routine should be specific enough to run without a lawyer. A named person checks the main platforms on a schedule, searches the supplier’s model numbers and the part numbers that appear in its catalogue, and keeps dated screenshots with the URL and the time. Trade fairs are checked against a list of the buyer’s current products rather than attended generally. Where a listing appears, the first step is a purchase rather than a letter, because a purchase produces evidence and a letter produces a warning.
When a factory is suspected of running a second shift
The phrase covers more conduct than the words suggest. A second shift can mean the factory running your tooling outside your ordered hours and selling the output under another brand. It can mean overrun production sold as “original” through a trading company, B-grade or reject units sold as “parallel” stock, your tooling used to make another customer’s product, production sub-contracted to a sister plant, or scrap reground and remoulded into units that carry your marks.
The commercial signals are consistent. A product appears at a price that cannot be made from new material. Supply becomes available in a quantity that no authorised channel can explain. Packaging differs in a way that suggests a different printing plate. Your own orders are short while the market is not. A trading company offers “factory direct” stock of a product that has one customer.
The first seventy-two hours decide how much of the case survives. The instinct is to call the factory and demand an explanation. That instinct destroys the evidence, because the factory has time to move the tooling, rewrite the production records and coach the staff. The sequence that preserves options is different.
Verify the rights before using them. Read the audit clause, the tooling clause, the records clause and the termination clause. Establish whether the buyer has a contractual right to inspect, whether notice is required, and whether an inspection can be conducted by a third party. Without a contractual right, access depends on consent or on a court order, and the strategy changes.
Preserve what exists. Capture the public evidence first: the listings, the prices, the seller identities, the screenshots with timestamps. Preserve the internal record: the disclosure log, the tooling register, the acceptance photographs, the first-off samples, the order history and the correspondence. None of this alerts the factory.
Buy the product. A test purchase through an unrelated buyer, preferably notarised, produces a physical unit with a chain of custody. Keep the packaging, the invoice, the courier record and the payment record. The unit itself is the exhibit: its cavity marks, its material, its firmware build identifier and its serial range connect it to a tool and a production run.
Do the arithmetic before the confrontation. Reconcile the material purchased against the material that the buyer’s orders should have consumed. A factory that bought 40 tonnes of resin and shipped product equivalent to 25 tonnes has an explanation to give. The same reconciliation can be done with packaging, labels, screws and connectors, and the strongest version uses two or three inputs that point the same way. This analysis is the single most persuasive document in a second-shift case, because it is arithmetic rather than accusation.
Then choose the instrument. A contractual audit demand, exercised with a technical expert and a photographer, is the fastest route where the clause supports it. An administrative complaint to the market supervision authorities produces an official record and a stop order. A civil claim with an application for evidence preservation puts a court officer in the factory. A customs recordal interrupts the export. A criminal referral reaches the individuals. The choice depends on whether the objective is to stop the conduct, recover the tooling, recover money or all three, and the objectives often point to different instruments in a different order.
The evidence that a factory generates in the ordinary course is more useful than anything a confrontation produces. Machine hour logs, shot counters, maintenance records, material purchase invoices, electricity bills, wage and overtime records, packaging purchase records and freight records all exist because the business needs them. Some are available through the audit clause, some only through a court. The buyer’s task is to know which is which before making a demand that closes the door.
What not to do is worth stating plainly. Do not confront the factory on a messaging app. Do not terminate the agreement before the evidence is preserved, because termination gives the factory a reason to clear the site. Do not accept a settlement that does not return the tooling, because a cash payment without the tool leaves the capability in place. Do not let the tooling leave the country without a record, and do not assume that a promise to stop is a stop.
Remedies
The remedy follows the objective. To stop the conduct, an injunction or an administrative action through the market regulator is usually fastest. To recover money, a civil damages claim, with evidence of the infringer’s sales and the buyer’s loss, is the route. For serious trade secret misappropriation, a criminal complaint reaches the individuals and changes the negotiating position, but it requires proof of secrecy measures, commercial value and loss.
In practice the strongest position combines a registered right, a documented trade secret programme and market evidence of copying. Each element is weak alone; together they are difficult to answer.
What “design” means in a supply chain
A product design is not one asset. It is a stack: the industrial design, the mechanical drawings, the electronic schematics, the firmware, the bill of materials, the test specifications and the process know-how that makes the whole thing manufacturable.
Each element attracts a different protection. The appearance may be a design patent. The mechanical features may be utility models. The core technology may be an invention patent. The drawings and firmware are copyright works. The process know-how is a trade secret. The brand is a trademark.
A protection programme that relies on one element is fragile. A supplier that copies the appearance can be stopped by a design patent, but a supplier that copies the process know-how needs a trade secret case, and a supplier that copies the firmware needs a copyright or software claim. The practical programme addresses all of them, in the order in which the information leaves the company.
The order matters because the assets leave at different times. The appearance is visible at the first meeting, before any document is sent. The drawings leave at quotation. The process know-how is transferred during trial production, when the factory’s engineers adjust the mould and learn what makes the part work. The firmware leaves at production. Each moment needs its own control, and a programme built only around the NDA is a programme built around the wrong moment.
The quotation-stage NDA in practice
The NDA signed at quotation stage is often the only agreement in place when the design is most exposed, and it is usually the weakest document in the file.
A workable quotation NDA has five features. It identifies the purpose narrowly — evaluation for quotation, not manufacture. It defines confidential information by category and by marking, so that the supplier cannot argue it did not know what was confidential. It limits the recipients to named individuals with a need to know, and requires the supplier to procure individual undertakings. It prohibits use for any other purpose and disclosure to any third party, including affiliates. And it provides for return or destruction on request, with a certification.
Two further points are worth adding for China. A Chinese-language version, or a bilingual version with a Chinese text that prevails, because a court will work from the Chinese text. And a governing law and forum that gives the buyer a practical remedy, which usually means arbitration rather than the supplier’s local court.
Where a supplier refuses to sign a quotation NDA, the refusal is itself information. A supplier that will not agree to keep a drawing confidential before quoting is a supplier that intends to use the drawing.
The clause that most often decides a case is the definition of confidential information. A definition that covers “all information disclosed by the buyer” is broad but vague, and a court may find that it did not put the supplier on notice about a particular drawing. A definition that lists categories, requires marking, and adds a catch-all for information that a reasonable recipient would understand to be confidential is more likely to hold up, because it works both with the marking regime and without it.
Copyright in drawings and software
Copyright arises automatically, and in China it can be registered. Registration is not a condition of the right, but it is evidence that a court will accept, and it is inexpensive.
Drawings, specifications, firmware and user interfaces are all capable of copyright protection. The agreement should assign or license the rights expressly, because a supplier that creates drawings from the buyer’s concepts may own the copyright in those drawings in the absence of an assignment.
The point is easy to miss when the supplier redraws. A factory that converts a sketch into a manufacturable drawing has created a work, and the copyright in that work may sit with the factory unless the contract says otherwise. The manufacturing agreement should assign it, or grant the buyer a perpetual licence to use and modify it, so that a later move to another factory does not require the first factory’s permission.
Software embedded in a product raises a separate issue. The supplier may write the firmware, or the buyer may supply it. Where the supplier writes it, the contract should assign the copyright and the source code, or at least grant a source code escrow. A product that cannot be maintained because the supplier holds the only copy of the source code is a product that cannot be moved.
Source code escrow is a compromise, and it should be drafted so that the release conditions are objective. A release on “the supplier’s insolvency or failure to support” invites an argument about what failure means. A release on a stated notice period and an uncured breach, with the source deposited in escrowed form and updated at each release, is usable. Where the firmware is developed in-house, the equivalent control is to keep the build environment and the signing keys, and not the source alone.
Patent strategy for hardware
China is a first-to-file jurisdiction, and the filing decision should be made before the design is disclosed.
For most hardware products the appropriate combination is a utility model on the mechanical structure, a design patent on the appearance, and an invention patent on the core technology. Utility models are registered after formal examination and are available within months, which suits products with a short commercial cycle. Invention patents take longer but provide stronger protection for the technology that differentiates the product.
Design patents protect the appearance and, since the 2020 amendment, run for fifteen years. They are particularly useful against copycat products sold online, because the comparison is visual and the infringement is easy to demonstrate.
Filing before disclosure also protects against a supplier filing on the buyer’s design. A supplier that files first creates a registered right that the buyer must invalidate or oppose, which is expensive and slow even where the buyer’s entitlement is clear.
The cost of the portfolio is modest against the tooling it protects. A utility model and a design patent on a single product cost less than the mould, and they are the rights that support a customs recordal and an online takedown. Companies that defer filing until the product is successful usually file after the disclosure that destroys novelty, and discover the problem when the application is examined.
Trade secret litigation: evidence and burden
A trade secret claim in China requires proof of three elements: that the information is not public, that it has commercial value, and that the owner has taken corresponding confidentiality measures.
The third element is where most claims fail. A buyer that signed an NDA but did not mark documents, did not restrict access and did not keep a disclosure log will struggle to show that it treated the information as secret.
The evidence that courts accept includes confidentiality clauses, individual undertakings, access logs, marking on documents, physical controls, and records of disclosures. The standard is proportionality: measures appropriate to the value of the information and the size of the business, not a perfect security programme.
The burden then shifts to the defendant to show that it obtained the information lawfully or that the information is public. In practice, a defendant that has the buyer’s drawings, with the buyer’s markings, and no explanation of how it obtained them, faces a difficult position.
The shift is not automatic, and it is worth knowing what triggers it. The buyer must present evidence that the defendant possesses information that is substantially the same and that the defendant had access, or that the circumstances make misappropriation likely. A drawing with the buyer’s watermark, found on the factory’s server or in a competitor’s files, does that. A general assertion that the products look similar does not.
Administrative and customs enforcement
Administrative enforcement through the market regulator is faster and cheaper than litigation, and it is available for trademark infringement, patent infringement in some circumstances, and unfair competition including trade secret misappropriation.
The remedy is an order to stop the conduct, a fine and, in some cases, the seizure of goods. Compensation is not awarded in the administrative process, but the decision is useful evidence in a subsequent civil claim.
Customs recordal is the most effective border measure. A registered patent, trademark or copyright can be recorded with customs, which then detains suspected infringing shipments on the owner’s application. For a manufacturer whose copies are destined for export, a customs detention can interrupt the business model in a way that a cease-and-desist letter cannot.
Recordal takes time to process and should be in place before it is needed. A company that records its rights only after a container has sailed has a claim and no shipment. The recordal should cover the rights that read on the product, and not the trademark alone, because a copy that carries no brand may still infringe a design patent.
Criminal route and its limits
Trade secret misappropriation and trademark counterfeiting can be prosecuted criminally. The threshold includes a requirement of significant loss or illegal gain, and the case must be brought by the public security authorities.
The criminal route is powerful because it reaches the individuals, not only the company, and because it changes the negotiating dynamics. It is also slow, uncertain and dependent on the local authorities’ priorities. It should be considered as part of a strategy rather than as a first step.
The practical value of a criminal referral often lies in what it does to the civil case. A police investigation can obtain records that a civil court would take months to order, and the prospect of individual liability changes the willingness of a factory’s managers to defend a position. The limitation is that the threshold is monetary and assessed locally, and a case that is obviously serious to the buyer may not meet it.
Contractual remedies and liquidated damages
A liquidated damages clause is the fastest remedy, because it avoids the need to prove loss.
The clause should be proportionate to the likely harm, because Chinese courts can reduce a penalty that is excessively high relative to actual loss. A clause that imposes a penalty of several times the contract value for any breach is likely to be reduced; a clause that ties the penalty to the value of the copied product, the number of units or the licence fee that would have been payable is more likely to be upheld.
The clause should also cover the specific conduct that matters: unauthorised production for third parties, disclosure to a competitor, use of tooling for another customer, and continued use after termination. A general confidentiality indemnity is less useful than a specific list.
A workable structure has three parts. A per-unit figure for unauthorised production, set at a multiple of the unit price that is defensible as an estimate of loss. A separate figure for unauthorised disclosure, tied to the development cost of the design or to a licence benchmark. And a continuing obligation, so that the penalty accrues for each day the conduct continues after notice, which converts a one-off breach into a reason to stop. Each figure should be justifiable by reference to something real, because a court asked to reduce an arbitrary number will.
Building a programme across suppliers
Most foreign buyers work with several Chinese suppliers, and the design leaks from the weakest link.
A programme that works has four elements. A standard NDA and manufacturing agreement used with every supplier, so that no relationship is governed by an old template. A disclosure log maintained centrally, so that the company knows what each supplier has seen. A register of filings, so that the company knows which designs are protected and where. And a monitoring routine that covers platforms, trade fairs and the suppliers’ own catalogues.
The programme does not need to be elaborate. It needs to be consistent, documented and applied before disclosure, because the value of every later remedy depends on what was done at the start.
Consistency is the part that fails. A company with eleven suppliers usually has four versions of the NDA, two of which predate the current confidentiality regime, and no record of which supplier signed which. The fix is administrative rather than legal: a single template, a register of signed versions, and a rule that no technical file leaves the company without a current agreement on file. That rule is enforceable by the person who controls the file server, which is more reliable than a policy addressed to everyone.
Documents, filings and timeline
The steps below run in a fixed order, and each one depends on the one before it.
| Step | Authority or counterparty | Typical timing | What foreign companies miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quotation NDA | Supplier | Before any technical discussion | Signed after drawings have already been sent |
| Design registration | National IP administration | Months for utility models and designs; years for invention patents | Filed after the product has been exhibited or sold |
| Manufacturing agreement | Supplier | Before tooling release | The quotation NDA is left in place as the production contract |
| Tooling acceptance and register | Internal | At tooling sign-off | No cavity samples, no photographs, no engraving |
| Customs recordal | Customs | After grant, before shipment | Recordal deferred until infringement is discovered |
| Monitoring | Internal | Continuous | No attribution marks, so a copy cannot be traced |
| Evidence preservation | Notary, court or police | Immediately on suspicion | Confrontation first, preservation second |
| Administrative complaint | Market supervision authorities | Weeks to months | Treated as a route to compensation |
| Civil claim | People’s court | Months to trial | No evidence preservation application at filing |
Cost and commercial impact
The programme costs less than the assets it protects, and the costs are predictable. Marking, logging and staged release are administrative. A bilingual NDA and a manufacturing agreement drafted for the relationship cost a fraction of the tooling. Utility models and design patents are inexpensive relative to the mould, and copyright registration is cheaper still.
The costs that surprise buyers are the ones incurred after something goes wrong. Duplicating a mould at short notice, qualifying a new factory and re-running certification can cost more than the original tooling and take a quarter. An injunction against a competitor does not recover the sales lost while the copies were on the market. A criminal case consumes management time for a year.
The commercial value of the programme shows up in three places. It preserves the option to move the tooling, which is the buyer’s main leverage in any negotiation with a factory. It supports an indemnity that the buyer can give to its own customers, because a documented programme is what makes the indemnity priceable. And it protects the valuation of the business, since a hardware company whose design can be copied by its own supplier is valued on the assumption that the margin will not last.
What to do next
- Map what is disclosed at quotation stage and reduce it to the minimum needed to quote.
- Mark all drawings and files, and keep a disclosure log from the first contact.
- Sign a specific NDA before any technical discussion, and obtain individual undertakings from the engineers involved.
- File utility models and design patents before disclosure for products with a commercial life beyond a year.
- Restructure the manufacturing agreement as a limited licence with a sub-contracting control and a return obligation.
- Build a tooling register with engraving, cavity samples and acceptance photographs, and verify use against machine records.
- Release files in stages, with a named recipient, a document identifier and a written acknowledgement at each stage.
- Monitor platforms and trade fairs, and record customs recordals for registered rights.
- Decide in advance whether the objective in an infringement scenario is to stop the conduct or to recover money, because the two paths diverge.
- Write the first seventy-two hours of a suspected second shift as a checklist, and test it before it is needed.
Where this leads
Tooling ownership and recovery deserve a guide of their own, and the practical mechanics are set out in Who Owns the Mould? Tooling Ownership and Recovery in China. The commercial architecture of the supply relationship is covered in Sourcing AI Hardware from China and China Manufacturing Contracts, and the licensing boundary that decides what a factory may do with your drawings is analysed in The Scope Clause: What a China Technology Licence Actually Grants.
For a programme built around a specific product, see the intellectual property protection service page or contact the firm.
Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article
Is an NDA enough to protect a design sent to a Chinese manufacturer?
No. An NDA is necessary but it is only a contractual claim after the fact. What decides whether the claim succeeds is whether the design was treated as confidential in practice: who received it, in what form, with what markings, under what access controls, and what record exists of the disclosure. A supplier that received a complete drawing set by messaging app can argue the information was not secret.
Should we patent in China before approaching a manufacturer?
Where the design is patentable and the market matters, file before disclosure. China is a first-to-file jurisdiction, and a supplier or a related entity that files first creates a costly problem even if the buyer ultimately wins. Utility model registration is fast and inexpensive for mechanical features, and design patents cover appearance; both are worth considering alongside invention patents.
Can we license a Chinese manufacturer to produce for us without transferring ownership?
Yes, and that is the correct structure. The manufacturing agreement should grant a limited licence to use the buyer's drawings, tooling and specifications solely to produce goods for the buyer, with no right to sublicense, no right to sell to third parties, and no ownership transfer. Technology transfer should be the exception, not the default, and it should carry a price.
What protective measures do Chinese courts look for in a trade secret case?
Courts look for measures that are proportionate to the information and actually applied: confidentiality markings, access restrictions, need-to-know distribution, signed confidentiality undertakings, physical and IT security, and records of disclosure. The standard is not perfection, but a supplier that received unmarked files with no access control will argue that the buyer did not treat the information as secret.
How do we find out if a supplier is selling our product to others?
Through the market: monitoring Chinese e-commerce platforms, trade fairs and export records, and checking the supplier's own catalogue and website. Serial numbers, unique components and software watermarks help attribution. Where infringement is found, customs recordal of patents and trademarks allows border seizure, which is often the fastest practical remedy.
What remedies are available if a supplier copies the design?
Civil remedies include injunction, damages, destruction of infringing goods and tooling, and account of profits; administrative enforcement through the market regulator is faster but limited in compensation; criminal prosecution is available for serious trade secret cases. The choice depends on the evidence and on whether the objective is to stop the conduct or to recover money.
Does Chinese law protect unregistered designs?
There is protection for packaging and product appearance under the Anti-Unfair Competition Law where the appearance is distinctive and has acquired influence, and copyright can subsist in drawings and models. But unregistered protection is narrower and harder to prove than a granted design patent. For products with a commercial life of more than a year, registration is usually worth the cost.