A foreign buyer spends six figures on a mould. The supplier quotes a piece price that amortises it, the relationship runs for two years, quality slips, the order moves, and the buyer discovers that the mould it paid for belongs on paper to the factory now holding it. The discovery usually arrives in the same week as the new supplier’s first production date, which is the worst possible week.

The dispute is common and almost entirely avoidable, because the law does not create it. Chinese law gives a buyer no default proprietary right over tooling it funded. Ownership follows the agreement and, where the agreement is silent, the evidence of who ordered, paid for and took delivery of the tool. In most relationships the supplier ordered the mould from a local toolmaker, paid for it and recovered the cost through the piece price, so the purchase order, the invoice, the delivery note and the possession all point one way.

Four levers decide the outcome, and they are separate. Title is created by the contract and the paper trail. Possession is a physical fact that gives the supplier leverage whatever the contract says. Money determines whether the supplier has a lawful claim that can support a lien. Registration is largely unavailable, which is why the first three matter so much. A buyer that works all four before the relationship sours has a recoverable asset. A buyer that works none of them has an argument about intention, which is the argument the supplier wins because it holds the mould.

Why the default position favours the supplier

Under the Civil Code, ownership of movable property generally passes on delivery, and possession is evidence of title. Tooling is movable property. There is no register of moulds, no certificate of ownership, and no filing that a buyer can make to announce to the world that a particular tool belongs to it.

That structure produces a predictable result. The supplier contracts with the toolmaker, takes delivery into its own factory, pays the invoice and books the asset. When the relationship ends, the supplier has possession, the paperwork and the physical facts. The buyer has a payment record and a recollection of what was agreed.

The buyer’s usual counter-argument is that it funded the tooling, so it must own it. The argument is intuitive and legally incomplete. Funding creates a claim for money, not a proprietary right, unless the contract says otherwise or the tooling can be traced to the buyer’s account. A buyer that paid an amortised piece price for two years has paid for parts, and the tooling component embedded in the price is a cost contribution rather than a purchase unless the contract says it is.

Three factors decide the outcome, and each is within the buyer’s control at the point of contracting.

Who contracted with the toolmaker. A buyer that contracts directly with the toolmaker and takes delivery in its own name has a clean chain of title. A buyer that leaves the contracting to the supplier has a chain with a gap in the middle.

Who is named as owner. A clause stating that the buyer owns all tooling it funds is effective where the tooling is identifiable. Without identifiability, the clause is a statement of intention that the supplier can dispute item by item.

Whether the tooling is identifiable. Serial numbers, ownership plates, a bailment schedule and photographs turn an argument about intention into an argument about a list. A list can be checked. Intention cannot.

The documentary reality matters more than the legal theory, because most of these disputes never reach a judgment. They are settled, or they are lost, on what the parties can produce in the first two weeks. The supplier produces a purchase order, an invoice and a delivery note. The buyer produces a supply agreement with a general clause about intellectual property and a schedule that refers to “tooling” without naming a single item.

DocumentWhat it provesWho usually holds it
Toolmaker purchase orderWho bought the toolThe supplier
Toolmaker invoiceWho paid, and how muchThe supplier
Delivery note to the factoryWho took deliveryThe supplier
Tooling schedule with serial numbersWhat the tool is, and whereThe buyer, if it was prepared
Bailment acknowledgementThat possession is held for the buyerThe buyer, if it was obtained
Ownership plate photographsPhysical marking consistent with the claimThe buyer, if the plates were fixed
Payment recordsWho funded, and how muchThe buyer

The buyer’s position improves with each row it can fill, and the first three are usually lost before the contract is signed. That is the point of the drafting that follows.

Ownership: what the clause must say

A tooling clause in a supply agreement is usually one sentence inside an intellectual property section. It needs to be a schedule.

The definition of tooling should be wide enough to cover what the factory actually holds. Moulds and dies are the obvious items. The estate also includes jigs, fixtures, gauges, checking fixtures, patterns, master models, electrodes, spare cavity blocks, hot runner systems, and test rigs with embedded software. A definition limited to “moulds” leaves the buyer arguing about the fixture that holds the part in the press, which is often as expensive as the mould and just as hard to replace.

ClausePurposeDrafting note
OwnershipNames the buyer as owner of all tooling it funds, including modifications and replacementsUse “all right, title and interest”, and cover replacements and spare cavities expressly
Schedule and identificationLists each item, serial number, location, replacement value and date of deliveryAnnex it, and update it whenever a tool is added
MarkingRequires a permanent ownership plate and photographs on deliverySpecify the plate content and who fixes it
Possession and bailmentRecords that the supplier holds the tooling for the buyer’s account, not as its own assetUse the word bailment, and state that possession is not evidence of ownership
Access and inspectionAllows the buyer or its representative to inspect on noticeInclude the right to photograph and to audit the schedule
Use restrictionProhibits use for other customers or products without written consentCover use of the tooling to make parts for the supplier’s own account
Maintenance and insuranceAllocates repair, calibration and insurance, and requires notice of damageTie maintenance to a schedule and to records
AmortisationStates whether the cost is recovered through piece price and what happens on early terminationPut the arithmetic in the contract
Removal and transferGrants the right to remove on notice and obliges the supplier to cooperate with a successorAdd a defined cooperation list, not a general promise
Lien waiverExpressly excludes any lien or retention right over the toolingPair it with a statement that the tooling is not an asset of the supplier

Two clauses carry most of the practical weight.

The schedule converts a dispute about ownership into a dispute about a list. It should be annexed to the agreement, signed by both parties, and updated whenever a tool is added, replaced or moved. Each line needs a serial number or a permanent identifying mark, a location that names the building and the bay where possible, a replacement value and the date the buyer’s funding was applied. A schedule with ten lines and no serial numbers is a schedule that will be argued about.

The removal right needs a cooperation obligation attached, because a right to remove without help is often unenforceable in practice. The supplier does not refuse; it simply does not schedule the crane, does not release the fixture drawings, does not brief the new factory on the process settings, and does not answer emails. The clause should list what cooperation means: access during a defined window, use of the factory’s lifting equipment at an agreed rate, release of tool drawings and process parameters, a signed condition report, and a named contact with a response time.

Ownership also needs to survive change. Where a mould is modified for a new part, the modification is funded by the buyer and the clause should say so. Where a mould base is shared between two buyers’ tools, the sharing should be documented, because a shared base is the item most likely to be retained when one relationship ends.

What ownership does not give the buyer is worth stating plainly. It does not give possession. It does not give access. It does not give the process know-how that makes the tool work, and it does not give the drawings if they sit on the supplier’s server. Each of those needs its own clause, and the absence of any one of them can make a valid title worthless at the moment it is needed.

Possession: bailment and the physical facts

Possession is where the law meets the factory floor.

A bailment arrangement is the legal form: the supplier holds the tooling for the buyer’s account, for a defined purpose, and must return it on demand. The document that records it should be short and specific. It names the items by schedule reference, states that possession is for the buyer’s account, states that the supplier has no proprietary interest, states that the tooling is excluded from the supplier’s assets in any insolvency, and states the return obligation.

The physical facts should match the document. An ownership plate fixed to the mould, photographed on delivery, with the buyer’s name and the schedule reference, is the single most useful item in a dispute, because it is visible to anyone who inspects the tool and it survives the loss of the file. Segregation in a marked area of the tool store, with the tools recorded in the factory’s own asset list as customer property, achieves the same purpose inside the supplier’s systems.

An access log matters more than companies expect. A buyer that inspects annually, photographs the plates, records the condition and keeps the report has a documented possession history. That history is what defeats the argument that the tooling was consumed, modified beyond recognition, scrapped or lost.

Maintenance sits with possession. The agreement should allocate routine maintenance, name the interval, require records, allocate wear parts, and set a threshold above which the buyer’s approval is needed for a major repair. A mould that is not maintained fails early, and the failure usually arrives when the buyer is trying to move production. A well-maintained mould can run for a very long time; a neglected one starts producing defects well before its nominal life, and a catastrophic failure can mean weeks of downtime and a rebuild.

Insurance is the other half. The supplier should insure the tooling at replacement value, name the buyer as loss payee, and notify damage, theft or destruction. The replacement value in the schedule should be the current cost to rebuild, not the historic cost, because that figure sets both the insured sum and the damages claim. A mould that cost 300,000 yuan to build may cost considerably more to replace at short notice, and the schedule should reflect the replacement figure.

Where the supplier does not build the tooling itself, the possession chain has a second link. The supplier instructs a specialist toolmaker, often in the same industrial park, and the toolmaker’s invoice is addressed to the supplier. If the relationship fails or the supplier becomes insolvent, the toolmaker may assert rights over the tool or refuse to release it to anyone other than its customer.

Three documents close that gap. A tripartite acknowledgement among the buyer, the supplier and the toolmaker confirming that the tool is held for the buyer. A toolmaker’s waiver of any lien over the tool in favour of the buyer. And, where the sums justify it, a direct contract between the buyer and the toolmaker for the build, with the supplier acting as technical coordinator.

A fourth situation is common in larger programmes: the tool is physically held at a tier-two factory that moulds parts for the tier-one supplier. The buyer may have no contractual relationship with the tier-two factory at all. The ownership chain has to be documented at each level, and the practical instrument is a short acknowledgement from the tier-two factory, obtained through the tier-one supplier, that the tool is held for the buyer’s account.

Payment: funding models, amortisation and early termination

Tooling is funded in one of three ways, and the choice affects ownership as much as cash flow.

ModelHow it worksOwnership positionMain risk
Outright purchaseBuyer pays the tooling cost as a separate line itemCleanest: invoice and payment name the buyerBuyer carries the capital and the risk of a poorly built tool
AmortisationSupplier pays the toolmaker and recovers the cost through the piece priceAmbiguous unless drafted: supplier holds invoice and possessionDispute on early termination about the unamortised balance
SharedBuyer funds the initial build; supplier funds maintenance and replacementNeeds a schedule that separates the twoBlurred boundary when a rebuild is needed

Outright purchase is the cleanest for ownership, because the invoice and the payment record name the buyer and the tooling schedule can be tied to a payment. It is also the model that gives the buyer the strongest position in a lien dispute, because the supplier never held the tool as its own asset.

Amortisation is cheaper in cash terms and creates the ambiguity that produces disputes. The supplier paid the toolmaker, holds the invoice and possesses the tool. The buyer’s only evidence is a price schedule that refers to tooling amortisation without saying who owns the asset. Where amortisation is used, the agreement should state expressly that the tooling is owned by the buyer from the date of first payment, that the supplier holds it on bailment, and that the amortised amount is a contribution to the buyer’s cost rather than a sale of the tooling to the supplier.

The arithmetic should be in the contract. The unamortised balance is a function of the tooling cost, the amortisation volume and the units shipped: cost multiplied by one minus units shipped divided by the amortisation volume. Three positions on early termination are workable, and the contract should choose one.

The buyer pays the unamortised balance and takes the tooling. The supplier retains the tooling and the unamortised balance is written off. The tooling is sold to a third party and the proceeds are shared in an agreed proportion.

Whichever is chosen, a price schedule that shows the tooling component separately, and a clause that states the consequence of early termination, convert a dispute about fairness into a calculation. The absence of that clause is why so many of these conversations end with both parties feeling cheated and neither being able to point to a term.

Payment terms interact with the lien. A supplier holding a mould can refuse to release it, and it may assert a lien under the Civil Code where it lawfully possesses the property and its claim arises from the same legal relationship — unpaid processing fees for parts made with that tooling, for example. The lien is not a general security right. It does not cover unrelated debts, and it can be resisted where the tooling was delivered for a defined purpose and the claim is unrelated to that purpose. But resisting takes time, and the practical consequence is that a buyer in a payment dispute may find its tooling frozen while the dispute is resolved.

The contractual answer is to separate the tooling from the commercial account. A bailment agreement, a written acknowledgement that the tooling is held for the buyer’s account, a prohibition on asserting a lien, and a mechanism for release on demand with the supplier’s cooperation stated expressly. Where the supplier insists on security, the buyer can offer a payment schedule, a bank guarantee or retention of title over finished goods, which are cleaner instruments than a claim over tooling.

Two payment practices reduce the risk further. Tooling payments tied to milestones — order placement, design freeze, first samples, acceptance — keep the buyer’s money behind the work rather than in front of it. A hold-back of a modest percentage until the tool has run a defined number of parts gives the buyer leverage at the point where defects appear.

Registration: what can be recorded and what cannot

Buyers often ask whether they can register the mould so that the world knows it is theirs. For most tooling, the answer is no.

There is no public register of ownership of tooling in China. The registration systems that exist for movable property record security interests, not title. A pledge of movable property is perfected by delivery of possession, which is unhelpful where the supplier holds the tool. A mortgage of movable property can be registered, and registration affects the position against third parties, but a mortgage is a security interest granted by an owner, not a record of who owns the asset.

The practical consequence is that title has to be proved by documents rather than by a register, and the documents have to be assembled before the dispute. That is why the schedule, the bailment acknowledgement, the invoice trail and the photographs do the work that a registration would do in a jurisdiction that maintains a tooling register.

Where a lender is involved — a bank financing the buyer’s tooling, or a lessor — the security documents and the registration protect the lender’s interest, and the buyer should ensure that the supplier has acknowledged the lender’s position. A supplier that has signed an acknowledgement to a bank is much less likely to assert a casual lien later.

Insolvency is where the absence of a register bites hardest. Tooling in the supplier’s possession may be treated as part of its assets, and a buyer without an ownership clause and an identification schedule is reduced to an unsecured creditor in the queue. Even with the clause, the administrator will ask which specific items are claimed, where they are, and how the buyer’s title is evidenced. A schedule with serial numbers answers that question in an afternoon. A general clause does not.

The practical protections are unglamorous. Keep the ownership acknowledgement current and re-signed when the supplier changes name or ownership. Inspect periodically and photograph the plates. Remove tooling that is not in active production. Where a tool must stay, consider third-party storage or a bonded arrangement with a logistics provider, so that possession does not sit with the party whose solvency is the risk.

Recovery: the removal operation

Removal is a technical operation before it is a legal one, and the technical assessment should be done before any threat is made.

Four questions decide whether removal is feasible.

QuestionWhy it mattersHow to answer it
Is the tool physically removable without damage?Some tools are built into the press or the lineEngineering inspection on site
Does it fit another press?A mould built for a 1,600-tonne press will not run on an 800-tonne machinePress specification comparison with the receiving factory
Can the process be replicated elsewhere?Some tools work only with the supplier’s settings and know-howProcess audit, parameter records, trial at the receiving factory
Does the supplier hold a payment claim that supports a lien?A live claim gives the supplier leverage whatever the contract saysAccount reconciliation before notice

Where removal is feasible, the sequence below is the one that preserves the position.

StepOwnerTypical timingOutput
Written notice under the agreementBuyer’s legal and procurementDay 1Notice citing the removal clause and the window
Account reconciliation and segregation of disputed sumsBuyer’s financeDays 1 to 5Statement separating tooling from parts
Joint inspection and condition reportBuyer’s engineering and the supplierDays 5 to 10Signed report with photographs
Access and rigging scheduleSupplier’s operations, confirmed by the buyerDays 10 to 15Dated slot, equipment list, named contact
Physical removalBuyer’s logistics contractorThe scheduled slotSigned receipt by the carrier
Condition assessment at destinationReceiving factoryOn arrivalReport against the pre-removal condition
Re-qualificationReceiving factory and the buyer’s quality teamWeeks after arrivalFirst-article approval

The condition report is the element companies skip and later regret. A joint inspection before removal, with photographs and a written report signed by both parties, prevents the argument that the tooling was damaged during removal or was already worn beyond use. The report should record the last production date, the maintenance history and any known defects.

Timing needs a defined window and a consequence for obstruction. Where the supplier refuses access, the buyer’s remedy is a court application, which takes months and costs more than most tools are worth. The contractual deterrents are a cooperation obligation with liquidated damages and a right to set off the cost of delay against sums owed. Neither is a substitute for a plan, but both change the supplier’s calculation.

Logistics should be planned with the same care as the legal notice. Heavy moulds need crane access, and some factories require a wall or roof opening. Transport needs a flatbed with the right capacity and a route survey for the destination. The receiving factory needs to confirm the press, the utilities and the qualification plan before the tool arrives, because a mould that arrives at a factory that cannot run it is a mould in storage.

Where removal is not feasible, the commercial alternatives are a new mould built from the buyer’s drawings, a licence of the tooling design to a new supplier, or a negotiated buy-out. The first is often cheaper than a dispute, and it is the reason the buyer should hold its own drawings and specifications regardless of who owns the tool.

Cross-border removal and customs

Moving tooling out of China is an export transaction, and the customs position has to be cleared before the truck arrives.

Three points decide the difficulty. The customs value, which should reflect the tool’s value and be supported by the invoice or the schedule. The proof of ownership, which is the same document set used in the dispute. And the export licence, where the tool incorporates controlled technology or is associated with a controlled process.

Where the tooling was imported temporarily, or built under a processing trade arrangement, the customs position has to be regularised before removal. A processing trade handbook that is not closed will hold the shipment. The same applies where the tooling was declared as production equipment under a specific regime and the regime’s conditions have not been met.

A buyer that removes tooling without clearing the customs position may find the shipment detained, and the delay can exceed the benefit of the move. The practical sequence is to confirm the customs status with the broker, obtain the ownership documents, agree the value, and only then schedule the carrier.

Where the tooling stays in China and moves to a new supplier, the transfer is domestic and simpler, but the same documentation — ownership, condition, receipt — should be used, because the old supplier may later claim that the tooling was never returned or was returned damaged.

Joint ventures, tiers and other structures that complicate title

Three structures create ownership questions that a straightforward supply agreement does not answer.

A joint venture holds tooling in its own right. Tooling contributed to the JV becomes an asset of the JV, and a parent that wants it back on exit needs a contractual right, not an assumption that it funded the asset and therefore owns it. The JV documents should state which party contributes which tool, on what terms, and what happens on dissolution: whether the tool is returned, bought out at a valuation or sold. A parent that contributes a mould without that clause has made a capital contribution to a company it may not control.

A tier-one supplier that uses the buyer’s tooling to make parts for a tier-two assembler creates a chain with three links and, usually, one contract. The buyer contracts with the tier-one supplier, the tier-one supplier contracts with the tier-two factory, and the tool may physically sit at either. Where the tool sits at the tier two, the buyer’s ownership claim runs through a party it did not contract with, and the practical answer is an acknowledgement obtained through the tier one: a short letter confirming that the tool is held for the buyer’s account, that it will not be used for other customers, and that it will be released on the buyer’s instruction.

A contract manufacturer that builds for several brands will often propose to use one mould base for two customers’ parts, changing only the inserts. The arrangement saves money and creates a shared asset that neither customer can remove without disrupting the other. Where it is accepted, the agreement should identify which components belong to which buyer, record the insert ownership separately from the base, and state what happens if one relationship ends.

Each structure has the same remedy: name the item, name the holder, and name the trigger for return. The documents are short. The disputes they prevent are long.

The file that decides a dispute

If a tooling dispute reaches a court or an arbitration, the case is usually decided on documents assembled before the relationship failed rather than on argument at the hearing.

DocumentWhat it establishesWhere to keep it
Tooling purchase order and invoiceWho bought and paid for the toolBuyer’s finance system, not the supplier’s file
Payment records tied to the scheduleWhich items the buyer fundedBuyer’s finance system
Tooling schedule with serial numbersWhat exists and whereAnnexed to the agreement and updated
Ownership and bailment clausesThe contractual positionSigned agreement
Photographs of the ownership platesPhysical marking consistent with the claimWith the schedule, dated
Inspection and condition reportsPossession history and maintenanceBuyer’s engineering file
Correspondence on maintenance and accessWhether the supplier behaved as a baileeBuyer’s contract file
Insurance certificates naming the buyer as loss payeeWhether the tool was coveredBuyer’s risk file

A buyer that can produce those documents is in a strong position even without a perfect contract, because the file tells a consistent story about who owned the tool, who held it and how it was treated. A buyer that cannot is reduced to arguing about intention, which is the argument the supplier wins because it holds the mould.

The file should be maintained by the buyer, not requested from the supplier when the dispute starts. A supplier that is asked for its tooling file at the moment of a dispute will produce the parts of it that support its position, and the buyer will spend the first month reconstructing what it should have kept.

Where foreign companies get this wrong

Six failures account for most of the losses we see.

The first is assuming that funding creates ownership. The buyer pays an amortised price for two years and believes it has bought the tool. The consequence is that it has bought parts, and the tool remains the supplier’s asset on the supplier’s books.

The second is accepting a general intellectual property clause as a tooling clause. “All intellectual property in the designs remains the buyer’s” says nothing about the physical mould. The consequence is a valid claim about drawings and no claim about the object that makes the parts.

The third is signing a schedule without serial numbers. The schedule lists “mould for enclosure, 2 sets”. The consequence is that the supplier can produce two moulds of its own and argue that the buyer’s are elsewhere, or that the buyer’s were replaced.

The fourth is leaving the toolmaker outside the documents. The supplier orders the tool, the toolmaker invoices the supplier, and the buyer has no relationship with the party that physically built and may still hold the tool. The consequence appears at the worst moment, when the toolmaker refuses to release the tool to anyone but its customer.

The fifth is discovering the lien after the dispute starts. The buyer stops paying an unrelated invoice, the supplier asserts a lien, and the tooling is frozen while the accounts are argued. The consequence is a delay measured in months, during which the new supplier’s line is idle.

The sixth is treating removal as a letter. The buyer sends a demand, the supplier does not respond, and the buyer discovers that it has no crane booking, no receiving factory qualification and no condition report. The consequence is a legal right that cannot be exercised before the season ends.

Cost and commercial impact

The cost of getting tooling ownership wrong is dominated by three items, and none of them is the legal fee.

The first is replacement. A new mould built from drawings takes weeks to months, depending on complexity, and the buyer pays twice for an asset it already funded. Where the drawings are held by the supplier, the delay is longer, because the design has to be reconstructed.

The second is downtime. A product line that stops while a mould is rebuilt or a dispute is resolved loses revenue that usually exceeds the tooling value. The cost is highest for a product with a short market window, which describes most AI hardware.

The third is the price of leverage. A buyer that needs the tool urgently pays whatever the supplier asks, whether that is the unamortised balance, an inflated release fee or a new supply agreement on worse terms. The negotiation happens at the moment of maximum weakness, which is why the terms should be agreed at the moment of maximum strength.

The cost of getting it right is modest by comparison: a schedule, a bailment acknowledgement, plates, a tripartite letter where a toolmaker is involved, insurance at replacement value, and a removal plan written while the relationship is good. Most of that is drafting and a factory visit.

The commercial structure also affects the price. A supplier that owns the tool has an incentive to amortise it over a long volume and to resist early termination. A supplier that holds the tool on bailment has less incentive to compete on the piece price, because it is not recovering capital. The funding model is therefore a commercial choice as well as a legal one, and the choice should be made deliberately rather than inherited from a template.

Practical checklist

The tooling file is one of the cheapest pieces of insurance in a China manufacturing programme, and it is almost always assembled after the event. A buyer that prepares it at signature, updates it at each engineering change and inspects once a year will never need the argument about intention.

Related reading: tooling cost structures in China, tooling maintenance across the mould lifecycle, protecting your design in Chinese contract manufacturing, and when a Chinese supplier ships defective goods. The firm’s commercial contracts, IP protection and commercial dispute teams draft tooling schedules, bailment acknowledgements and removal plans, and act when a factory will not release the tool.

Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article

Does the buyer automatically own tooling it pays for in China?

No. Chinese law does not confer ownership on the party that funded the tooling; ownership follows the agreement and, in its absence, is decided by evidence of who acquired the tooling and on whose behalf. Where the supplier ordered the mould in its own name, from its own account, the paper trail points to the supplier. The ownership clause is therefore the whole of the buyer's position.

Can the supplier retain our mould until we pay outstanding invoices?

It may claim a lien under the Civil Code where it lawfully possesses the tooling and the claim arises from the same legal relationship — for example, unpaid processing fees for the parts made with that tooling. The lien is not unlimited: it does not cover unrelated debts, and it can be resisted where the tooling was bailed to the supplier for a specific purpose. Disputes are common and are decided on the contractual arrangement and the possession history.

How do we prove the mould is ours if the relationship breaks down?

With a combination of documents: the tooling agreement naming the buyer as owner, the purchase invoice for the mould, a bailment schedule listing each item and its serial number, photographs of the ownership plate, and the supplier's written acknowledgement on delivery. Without these, the buyer is arguing about intention rather than title.

What should the tooling agreement cover?

Ownership and the obligation to mark, a schedule identifying each item by serial number and location, access and inspection rights, maintenance and insurance obligations, amortisation and whether the cost is recovered through piece price, restrictions on use for other customers, and return or transfer on termination, including the supplier's duty to cooperate with a new manufacturer.

Can we move the tooling to another factory if quality does not improve?

Only if the agreement gives you that right, and only if the tooling is physically removable and technically portable. Many moulds are matched to a specific press, and some processes cannot be transferred without the supplier's know-how. A right of removal without a right of access and a cooperation obligation is of limited value.

What happens to tooling if the supplier becomes insolvent?

Tooling in the supplier's possession is at risk of being treated as part of its assets, and the buyer's claim may be reduced to an unsecured one unless ownership is documented and the tooling is identifiable. Registration is not available for most tooling, so the practical protection is prompt removal, a written acknowledgement and, where possible, physical separation or third-party storage.

Is it better to buy tooling directly rather than through the supplier?

Often yes. If the buyer contracts with the toolmaker, pays it directly and takes delivery into its own name, the ownership chain is clearer and the supplier's lien is harder to assert. The trade-off is that the buyer takes on the toolmaker relationship, the technical liaison and the risk of a poorly built mould.

Geason Law Offices AI Industry Research Group | Reviewed by He Qianggao (Lawyer License No. 14403201310092337, 10+ years of practice)