In a Chinese dispute, the party that moves first on assets usually wins the economics, whatever the merits. Judgment is slow; assets are fast. A supplier facing a claim can move receivables, empty accounts, transfer equity or ship inventory within days of learning that a dispute is coming.
Property preservation is the mechanism that prevents this. It is available before and during proceedings, it can be obtained quickly where the application is well prepared, and it is often the single most valuable step in a cross-border dispute with a Chinese counterparty.
Three things decide whether it works: whether the application says enough for a court to act, whether the security is in a form the court accepts, and whether the freeze is implemented before the assets move. Each is a separate problem with its own failure mode, and each can be solved in advance. This guide deals with all three in the order in which they arise.
What preservation does
A preservation order restricts the respondent’s ability to deal with specified assets. It does not transfer ownership and it does not decide the dispute. It freezes the position until the case is resolved.
The scope is broad: bank accounts, real estate, equity interests, receivables, inventory, equipment, vehicles and intellectual property. In practice, bank accounts and real estate account for most applications, because they are the easiest to identify and the most liquid.
Two forms matter. Property preservation freezes assets. Behaviour preservation restrains conduct — an ongoing infringement, a transfer of technology, a disposal of tooling — and is used where the harm cannot be remedied by money alone.
A third distinction is procedural rather than substantive, and it determines the timetable. Preservation applied for before a case is filed is decided by the court that would hear the substantive dispute, on an urgent basis, and requires the applicant to file within a short period afterwards. Preservation applied for during the case is decided by the court already seized of it, and is integrated into the case file. The first is faster to obtain and more demanding to justify; the second is cheaper in security and slower to arrange, because the case must first be accepted.
Before or during proceedings
During proceedings. The application is made to the court hearing the case, at any stage before judgment. This is the most common route and the one with the lowest security requirement in practice.
Before proceedings. Available in urgent circumstances, where the respondent may dispose of assets before a case can be filed. The applicant must commence proceedings within a defined period after the order — typically thirty days — or the preservation is released. The urgency requirement is real, and the security requirement is usually higher.
In support of arbitration. For arbitration seated in mainland China, the application is made to the court through the arbitration institution. The institution transmits the application, and the court decides. For foreign-seated arbitration, the route is less direct and slower, which matters when the assets are the reason for the dispute.
The choice between the three is not simply a matter of timing. Pre-litigation preservation is granted on a file that contains the claim but not yet a defendant’s answer, so the court scrutinises the applicant’s evidence more closely and sets security higher. In-suit preservation is decided with the pleadings in front of the judge, which usually helps a well-pleaded claimant and hurts one whose claim is thin. Where the case is ready to file, filing it and applying in-suit is often the better route even at the cost of a few days, because the security is lower and the freeze is harder to attack as premature.
The application
A successful application has four components.
A prima facie claim. The court does not decide the merits, but it needs to see that the claim is arguable and that the applicant is likely to succeed. Contracts, invoices, delivery records and correspondence are usually enough at this stage.
Urgency or necessity. The applicant should explain why preservation is necessary — the respondent’s financial position, a history of asset transfers, the nature of the assets, the risk of removal.
Identified assets. This is where most applications fail. A general assertion that the respondent has assets is not actionable. A bank account number, a property registration number, a company name with its registration number and shareholding, or a named customer with an identified receivable is actionable.
Security. The court sets the amount, commonly around thirty per cent of the value preserved, and accepts a guarantee, a deposit or an insurance product. Security is not a fee; it is returned or released when the case concludes, subject to any claim for wrongful preservation.
The application document, element by element
The application is a short document, usually two to four pages, and the court reads it in that order. Each element has a conventional form, and a departure from it costs time.
| Element | What the court expects to see | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Parties | Full registered names, unified social credit codes, addresses and legal representatives for both sides | An error in the respondent’s name produces a freeze that the bank cannot match to an account |
| The claim | The cause of action, the sum claimed, the contractual basis and the calculation | The preserved amount cannot exceed the claim, and the calculation is the ceiling |
| The request | Each asset identified separately, with the amount to be frozen against each, and a total cap | A single global request without allocation is returned for amendment |
| The necessity | Facts showing a risk of disposal: overdue payments, a change of account, a related-party transfer, a winding-up petition elsewhere | The court is not obliged to freeze merely because a claim exists |
| The security | The form offered, the issuer and the instrument reference | The ruling is not issued until the security is in place |
| Attachments | Contract, invoices, delivery notes, statements, demand letter, asset evidence, corporate documents, power of attorney | The file is judged as a whole; a missing invoice can delay the ruling by a week |
Three drafting points are worth stating plainly.
The request should be written so that it can be copied into the ruling. “Freeze the respondent’s account number 1234 at the Shenzhen branch of [bank], up to RMB 2,000,000” is a request a court can grant. “Freeze the respondent’s bank accounts up to the amount of the claim” is not, because the court cannot identify the account and the bank cannot implement the order.
The total cap should be stated once, and the individual amounts should sum to no more than it. Where the applicant asks for three accounts up to the full claim on each, the court will treat the request as seeking three times the claim and reduce it, and the reduction is recorded in a way that a respondent can later use in a wrongful-preservation claim.
The necessity section should be factual rather than adjectival. A history of late payment, an unexplained change of receiving bank in the last quarter, a new shareholder introduced offshore, a related-party sale of the main production equipment, or a supplier’s public complaint about non-payment — each is a fact a court can weigh. “The respondent is likely to transfer assets to avoid enforcement” is a conclusion, and conclusions without facts are the most common reason an urgent application is refused.
Asset intelligence
The quality of the application depends on the quality of the asset information. Four sources are worth developing before filing.
Public records. The National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System, judgment and enforcement databases, and equity registration records show the respondent’s corporate structure, shareholders, branches and prior litigation.
Commercial relationships. The respondent’s customers, suppliers and landlords often know where assets are, and invoices and contracts reveal bank details.
The applicant’s own records. Prior payments from the respondent contain account numbers and bank names, which are often the most reliable starting point.
Court enforcement records. Where the respondent has been a judgment debtor before, the enforcement file may identify assets and accounts.
The applicant’s own records deserve first place in the sequence. A finance team can extract, from two or three years of remittance advices, the paying entity, the bank, the branch and the account number. That is the particular the court needs, and it is already in the applicant’s files. Applications that begin with a database search and end with a general description of the respondent’s business are usually applications that did not start with the statements.
Two further sources are specific to the Chinese market. Equity pledges and share charges recorded on the register identify the lenders with which the respondent deals, and a lender’s due-diligence file is a map of the borrower’s accounts. And procurement and tender announcements, published by state-owned customers, identify the respondent’s contracts, its bidding entity and sometimes its bank account for bid bonds.
Scope and proportionality
Preservation should be proportionate to the claim. A court may reduce an excessive application, and a respondent may claim damages where the preservation was wrongful or excessive.
Two practical limits apply. Some assets are exempt or partially exempt — basic living expenses, certain social security funds, and assets necessary for the respondent’s basic operations in defined circumstances. And preserving assets that belong to a third party, such as goods held on consignment, invites a challenge and a damages claim.
A third limit is arithmetic. The preserved amount is capped by the claim, not by the value of the asset. Freezing a factory worth ten times the claim is not permitted; freezing the land use right up to the value of the claim is. In practice the court registers the freeze on the asset and records the amount secured, and the applicant should state that amount in the request.
Wrongful preservation
Where the applicant’s claim fails, or the preservation was excessive, the respondent can claim damages for losses caused by the freeze — lost business, financing costs, reputational harm. The security is the first source of compensation, and the claim can exceed it.
This is why preservation should be evidence-based rather than tactical. An application supported by contracts, delivery records and identified assets is defensible even if the case ultimately fails on a point of law. An application used to pressure a counterparty is the kind that generates a counterclaim.
Timing and sequencing
The sequence that works is: identify assets, prepare the substantive claim, prepare the preservation application and security in parallel, file the case and the application together, and follow up on implementation.
Implementation is not automatic. Bank freezes are usually implemented quickly once the ruling is served on the bank. Real estate and equity freezes require registration with the relevant authority, and the applicant’s representative often needs to follow up to ensure the registration is completed.
The timeline, stage by stage
The table below is a realistic sequence for an in-suit application in a court with a normal commercial caseload. The durations assume a complete file; each missing document restarts the clock.
| Stage | What happens | Typical timing | What foreign applicants miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evidence assembly | Contract, invoices, delivery notes, statements, demand letter, asset particulars | 3–10 days | The demand letter is often skipped; without it the urgency argument is weaker |
| Security arrangement | Insurance policy, bank guarantee or cash deposit into the court account | 3–7 days | The insurer must be on the court’s approved list; a foreign guarantee is usually refused |
| Filing | The case and the preservation application are lodged together | 1 day | Filing the case first and the application later loses a week and gives the respondent notice |
| Acceptance and fee | The court accepts the file, assigns a case number and assesses the fees | 1–5 days | The preservation fee is separate from the case fee and is capped, so it does not scale with the amount |
| Ruling | The court reviews the application and issues a ruling | Days where urgency is accepted; longer where the file is thin | A ruling is not a freeze; nothing has happened until it is served |
| Service on the bank or registry | The court serves the ruling; the bank blocks the account | 1–3 days for a bank; 1–3 weeks for property or equity registration | The applicant’s representative must follow up; courts do not confirm implementation unprompted |
| Written confirmation | The bank or registry confirms the balance or registration | 1–2 weeks | Obtain it; the confirmation is the evidence that the freeze exists |
Two features of that timetable are worth emphasising. The ruling is the fastest part of the process and the least useful on its own. And the security is the longest lead item, because it involves a third party — an insurer, a bank or a treasury function — over which the applicant’s lawyers have no control. Arranging security before the application is drafted, rather than after the court asks for it, is the single change that most shortens the timeline.
The freeze is also time-limited. A bank freeze runs for a fixed term, commonly one year, and must be renewed before it expires if the case is still running or enforcement has begun. Real estate and equity freezes run longer but are also finite. A creditor that obtains a freeze and then forgets the expiry date has bought a year, not a judgment, and the renewal application must be made before the term ends, not after.
Preservation before arbitration: the mechanics
Where the contract provides for arbitration seated in mainland China, the route to preservation runs through the institution rather than the court directly. The applicant files the preservation application with the arbitration commission, which transmits it to the competent court together with the acceptance materials. The court decides, and the institution relays the ruling.
The step adds time, usually several days and sometimes more where the file is incomplete, and it adds a document requirement: the court wants to see that the arbitration has been accepted, which means the case must already be registered. Applicants who prepare the application and the arbitration notice in parallel lose less ground than those who file the arbitration first and turn to preservation afterwards.
For arbitration seated outside the mainland, the position is less settled. Chinese courts have jurisdiction to grant preservation in aid of foreign-seated arbitration in some circumstances, but the route is not uniform across courts and the application is often made to the court at the place where the assets are located. The practical consequence is delay, and delay is the one thing preservation cannot afford. Where assets in China are the reason for the dispute, a mainland seat removes an entire layer of uncertainty.
What a bank freeze actually captures
A bank account freeze under a preservation order captures the balance at the moment the bank implements the order, and it prevents further withdrawals. It does not necessarily prevent credits. Incoming payments may still be received, and the frozen amount may then exceed the balance that existed when the order was served.
That feature is useful. A supplier with receivables from large customers will continue to collect, and each collection increases the amount secured. It also creates a management obligation: the applicant should monitor the account and consider whether to apply for an increase in the preserved amount if significant sums arrive.
Two practical points follow. The application should identify the account precisely — bank name, branch, account name and number — because a freeze served on the wrong branch may not be implemented. And the applicant should expect the bank to require the original ruling and proof of service, which means the court’s implementation documents must be collected rather than assumed.
A third point concerns multiple accounts. Where the respondent banks with several branches of the same bank, the court may issue one ruling covering several accounts, but the branches implement independently. The applicant should list every account it knows of, because the court will not search the bank’s systems on its own initiative, and the freeze on the main account is of limited value if the operating account at another branch remains open.
Real estate, equity and inventory
Real estate preservation is registered with the local property registration centre. It is slow relative to a bank freeze, but it is durable and it is difficult to reverse without the court’s order.
Equity preservation is registered with the market supervision authority and prevents the shareholder from transferring or pledging the interest. It is particularly useful against holding companies whose only real asset is a subsidiary, because it reaches the value indirectly and it signals the dispute to anyone conducting diligence on the respondent.
Inventory and equipment preservation requires the court to identify, seal and store the goods. It is expensive, it creates custody issues, and it is rarely proportionate unless the goods are the subject matter of the claim or are about to leave the country.
Intellectual property preservation is available in principle but uncommon in commercial disputes. It is more often encountered in infringement actions, where the court may order a party to cease using a mark or a work pending trial.
The security requirement in practice
Security is set by the court, commonly at around thirty per cent of the value preserved, though the percentage varies with the court and the asset. It can be provided as a cash deposit, a bank guarantee, a guarantee from a qualified entity, or an insurance policy issued by a company on the court’s approved list.
The choice matters commercially. Cash ties up working capital for the duration of the case, which may be a year or more. A bank guarantee costs a fee and requires credit lines. Preservation insurance has become the most common solution for foreign applicants because it is priced as a premium rather than a deposit and does not consume credit capacity.
Applicants should confirm the court’s accepted forms before arranging security, because a guarantee from an insurer the court does not recognise will delay the application and may cause the assets to move while the file is being corrected.
Four questions determine the amount and the form, and it is worth asking them before the application is filed.
How strong is the claim on the papers? A claim supported by signed delivery notes and an unrebutted statement of account attracts a lower percentage than a claim that depends on disputed oral assurances. The court’s discretion is exercised on the material in front of it, and the material is the applicant’s to choose.
Is the application pre-litigation or in-suit? Pre-litigation applications carry a higher percentage because the respondent has not yet had an opportunity to answer.
Is the applicant foreign? A foreign applicant without assets in China may be asked for a higher percentage, because the court’s ability to recover from the applicant if the preservation proves wrongful is otherwise theoretical.
Is the asset liquid? A bank account can be released quickly if the claim fails; a sealed production line cannot. Illiquid assets tend to attract a higher percentage.
The forms differ in ways that matter to a treasury department. A cash deposit is paid into the court’s account, in RMB, and is returned when the case concludes — after the judgment takes effect, or after the preservation is released. It is money out of the business for the duration, and it does not earn interest for the applicant. A bank guarantee is issued by a bank branch the court accepts, usually a Chinese-licensed bank, and requires a credit line or a counter-guarantee; a guarantee from a foreign bank without a mainland presence is normally refused. A corporate guarantee is accepted only from an entity the court considers good for the amount, which for a foreign applicant usually means a mainland affiliate with assets. Insurance is the most flexible: the premium is a cost, not a deposit, it is not returned, and the policy responds if the preservation is found wrongful.
Two adjustments are possible after the event. The court may reduce the security where the claim is later shown to be strong, or where the preserved assets are worth less than assumed; and it may require a top-up where the preserved amount increases because credits have arrived in a frozen account. Both require an application, and both are easier where the applicant has kept the file organised.
Security is released, not forfeited, when the case ends in the applicant’s favour. Where the applicant loses, the security is applied to the respondent’s proven losses, and any balance is returned. The respondent’s claim is not capped by the security, which is why the amount of the freeze should be defensible on the documents rather than set at the maximum the court will allow.
How wrongful-preservation claims are assessed
A respondent whose assets have been frozen can claim damages where the preservation was wrongful. Wrongfulness is not limited to bad faith. A claim that fails on the merits can support a damages claim if the preservation was excessive or if the applicant knew, or ought to have known, that the basis was thin.
The loss claimed is usually the cost of the freeze: interest on facilities drawn to replace frozen funds, penalties under contracts that could not be performed, lost opportunities that can be evidenced. Courts scrutinise causation, and general assertions of reputational harm are rarely compensated.
The security is the first source of recovery, but the claim is not capped by it. That asymmetry is why preservation should be evidence-based. An application supported by contracts, delivery records and identified assets is defensible even if the case ultimately fails on a point of law; an application used to pressure a counterparty is the kind that generates a counterclaim and a costs order.
Preservation against a party in financial distress
Where the respondent is already in difficulty, preservation competes with other creditors. A freeze obtained before insolvency proceedings begin secures priority in practice, because the preserved assets are outside the pool available to the administrator. A freeze obtained afterwards is likely to be stayed.
That timing question is the reason to act on the first signs of distress: delayed payment, a change of bank account, a sudden resignation of the finance director, or a supplier complaining that it has not been paid. None of those facts proves insolvency, but together they support the urgency requirement in a pre-litigation application.
Where the respondent has already entered reorganisation, the applicant should consider whether the claim can be filed in the reorganisation rather than pursued separately. The preservation route is largely closed, and the practical question becomes the ranking of the claim.
Cross-border preservation: what is and is not possible
Chinese courts do not enforce foreign preservation orders as such. A freezing injunction from an English or Hong Kong court has no direct effect on assets in the mainland, and an applicant who obtains one should not assume that the mainland assets are protected.
The workable routes are three. A mainland preservation application in support of mainland litigation or a mainland-seated arbitration. A preservation application in support of foreign-seated arbitration, where the court accepts jurisdiction. And, in limited circumstances, a preservation order obtained in Hong Kong or another jurisdiction over assets located there, which may include shares in an offshore holding company that owns the mainland operating business.
The third route is often overlooked. Where the Chinese counterparty is held through a BVI or Cayman company, freezing the offshore shares can be more effective than chasing mainland assets, because the offshore court has jurisdiction over the shareholder and the order does not depend on Chinese enforcement.
Implementation failures and how to avoid them
Most preservation applications that fail do so for reasons that were avoidable.
The asset description is too general. “Bank accounts of the respondent” is not actionable; the court needs the bank, the branch and the account.
The security is in the wrong form. The court has an approved list, and a guarantee from an unlisted provider will be rejected.
The urgency is not evidenced. A pre-litigation application requires a reason why the case cannot wait, and a bare assertion that the respondent may dispose of assets is not enough.
The implementation is not followed up. A ruling is not a freeze. The applicant’s representative should confirm with the bank or the registry that the order has been registered, and should obtain written confirmation.
Preservation in technology and IP disputes
In disputes involving technology, tooling or designs, the asset that matters may not be money. It may be the mould, the source code repository, the training dataset or the production line that is continuing to use a misappropriated process.
Behaviour preservation is the tool. It can restrain continued use of a mark, continued production using a transferred process, or continued sale of infringing goods. The application is harder than a bank freeze because it requires the court to accept that the conduct is ongoing and that the harm cannot be measured in money.
Where the technology is embodied in tooling held by the manufacturer, preservation of the tooling itself may be the practical step, particularly where the manufacturer is also a competitor or is close to insolvency. The application should describe the tooling precisely — asset numbers, location, photographs — and should address custody, because the court will not seal equipment that is essential to an ongoing production line without a plan for its care.
Evidence preservation is the companion measure in these cases, and it is often more valuable than a freeze. An order requiring the respondent to preserve and produce server logs, version histories, training records or delivery data prevents the destruction that typically follows a dispute becoming known, and the material it captures is what the substantive case will turn on. Applications that combine a property freeze with an evidence preservation request are more likely to be granted in full, because the court sees a coherent purpose rather than pressure on the respondent’s cash.
A worked sequence
A foreign licensor discovers that its Chinese licensee has sublicensed the technology to an affiliate and stopped paying royalties. The licensor has six weeks before the licensee’s financial year ends and the affiliate is expected to distribute profits.
Week one: obtain the licensee’s payment records, identify the receiving bank and the affiliate’s registration details, and prepare the demand letter that will support the claim.
Week two: prepare the arbitration notice and the preservation application in parallel, and arrange preservation insurance.
Week three: file the arbitration, obtain acceptance, and file the preservation application through the institution.
Week four: the court rules; security is lodged; the freeze is served on the bank.
Week five: confirm implementation in writing and consider whether the affiliate’s account should also be frozen.
The sequence is not unusual, and it is not fast. It works because the asset intelligence was done before the dispute crystallised, and because the application and the claim were prepared together rather than in sequence.
What to do next
- Identify the respondent’s assets before filing, using public records and the applicant’s own payment history.
- Prepare the substantive claim and the preservation application in parallel.
- Decide between pre-litigation and in-suit preservation on the basis of urgency and evidence.
- Provide security in the form the court accepts, and budget for it.
- Keep the application proportionate to the claim to avoid a wrongful-preservation counterclaim.
- Follow up on implementation with the bank or the registry.
- For arbitration, apply through the institution and allow for the extra step.
Our China-related commercial disputes practice prepares and runs preservation applications in litigation and in support of arbitration, including the security arrangements and the follow-up on implementation. Two related guides explain what happens after the freeze: Enforcing a Foreign Arbitral Award in China covers the recognition and enforcement stage that a preservation order protects, and Arbitration or Chinese Courts? Drafting the Dispute Clause explains why the seat chosen in the contract determines how quickly preservation can be obtained.
Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article
What is property preservation in China?
A court order that restricts the respondent's ability to deal with specified assets while proceedings are pending. It can apply to bank accounts, real estate, equity, receivables, inventory and intellectual property, and it is the Chinese equivalent of a freezing order, although the mechanism and the procedure differ.
Can preservation be obtained before a lawsuit is filed?
Yes, in urgent circumstances, but the applicant must commence proceedings within a defined period after the order is made, typically thirty days, or the preservation is released. Pre-litigation preservation requires a showing of urgency and usually a higher level of security.
How much security is required?
The court has discretion, and the amount depends on the assets and the risk of wrongful preservation. In practice, security of around thirty per cent of the amount preserved is common for applications involving identified assets, and courts may require more where the claim is uncertain or the assets are illiquid. Security can be provided by a guarantee, a deposit or an insurance product.
Can preservation support arbitration?
Yes, for arbitration seated in mainland China. The application is made to the court through the arbitration institution, and the court decides whether to grant it. For arbitration seated outside the mainland, the route to a Chinese court is less direct and the timing less predictable, which is a practical reason to consider a mainland seat where assets are in China.
What assets can be preserved?
Bank accounts, real estate, equity interests in companies, receivables, inventory, equipment and intellectual property. The application must identify the assets with enough precision for the court to act, so bank account numbers, property registration details or company names and registration numbers are essential.
What happens if the preservation was wrongful?
The respondent can claim damages for losses caused by the preservation where the applicant's claim fails or the preservation was excessive. The security is the first source of compensation. This is why the application should be proportionate and supported by evidence rather than used as pressure.
How long does preservation take?
Where the application and security are in order, a ruling can be issued within days and implemented quickly, particularly for bank accounts. Real estate and equity transfers of the freeze to the registry take longer. The timing depends on the court's workload and on how precisely the assets are identified.