The quotation is competitive, the samples work, and the factory has made something similar for a European brand. Six months later the mould is at a toolmaker nobody has heard of, the firmware on the production units differs from the approved sample, the certification on the box is Chinese rather than European, and the customer’s first container is held at destination because the exporter of record is not the company that signed the contract. None of these failures was caused by price. Each was caused by a handover that nobody documented.
Sourcing AI hardware from China is a sequence of transfers. A design leaves your engineering team and becomes a supplier’s drawing. A drawing becomes a tool. A tool becomes a qualified part. A qualified part becomes a production unit. A production unit becomes a shipped good, and then a warranty obligation. At each transfer, something of value changes hands: title, risk, responsibility, data or liability. The contract that governs the transfer is the only thing that determines who bears the loss when the transfer goes wrong.
This guide follows the chain in order and names the document that should govern each stage. It is written for the buyer, not the supplier, and it assumes no prior knowledge of Chinese contract practice. Where a rule depends on local implementation, the guide says so rather than guessing at a number.
The chain is a sequence of handovers
The most useful way to read a manufacturing relationship is as a series of gates. Nothing moves to the next gate until a document closes the current one. When a programme fails, the post-mortem usually finds a gate that was skipped, or a document that was signed by someone without authority, or two documents that said different things and no clause saying which prevailed.
| Stage | What is handed over | Document that governs it | Evidence that closes the stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design release | Drawings, bill of materials, firmware, test specification | Technical annex and design freeze record | Signed freeze record carrying a revision number and a date |
| Confidentiality | Drawings and process data | Non-disclosure and trade secret agreement | Executed NDA, dated before the first disclosure |
| Tooling | Money, then a physical asset | Tooling purchase order, tooling schedule and bailment clause | Tooling schedule with serial numbers, and a title plate on the tool |
| Qualification | A part that meets specification | First-article approval and golden sample record | First-article report and a golden sample signed by both quality managers |
| Volume supply | Units, on a schedule | Frame agreement plus purchase order | Purchase order referencing the frame agreement and the technical annex |
| Change | A revised design or process | Engineering change note and written change order | Approved change note with an effective date and a validation record |
| Compliance | A classification, a licence, a certificate | Supplier declaration, export licence, certificate of conformity | Classification statement, licence copy and certificate on file |
| Shipment | Possession, risk and sometimes title | International sale term plus bill of lading | Export declaration, bill of lading and certificate of origin that name the same entity |
| Payment | Cash against documents | Payment clause, letter of credit, guarantee | Payment confirmation matching the invoice and the contracting entity |
| After-sales | A failed unit and a liability | Warranty and returns procedure | RMA record with a diagnosis and a warranty decision |
Read the table as a checklist. A programme that cannot point to a signed document at each line is carrying an unallocated risk, and the risk will be allocated by a court or an arbitrator after the loss has occurred, on the basis of whatever evidence survives.
The document chain, in the order it has to be signed
Sequence matters as much as content. A confidentiality agreement signed after the drawings have been sent protects nothing that was already disclosed. A quality agreement signed after the first purchase order is a variation of terms the supplier has already accepted, and the supplier will say so. The chain below runs from the first contact to the first shipment, and each link names the person who should own it on the buyer’s side.
| Order | Document | What it has to contain | Buyer’s owner | Supplier’s owner | What breaks if it is late |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mutual NDA and trade secret agreement | Definition covering drawings, process parameters, firmware and yield data; return and destruction; liquidated damages a court will enforce | Legal counsel | Authorised signatory or in-house legal | Disclosed material may lose trade secret status, and there is no remedy for the first leak |
| 2 | Frame agreement | IP ownership, liability, termination, governing law, arbitration seat, order of precedence | Legal counsel with finance | General manager or legal | Purchase order terms become the whole contract by default |
| 3 | Design release and technical annex | Frozen revision number, bill of materials, test specification, firmware and calibration data, change control | Engineering lead | Programme manager | The factory works to the marked-up email, not the drawing |
| 4 | Tooling agreement and tooling schedule | Title, bailment, marking, insurance, maintenance, lien waiver, removal and transfer rights | Procurement with finance | Finance director | The buyer pays for an asset it cannot prove it owns |
| 5 | Quality agreement | Sampling plan, acceptance criteria, inspection period, audit rights, traceability, warranty handling | Quality manager | Quality manager | Acceptance is deemed at shipment and latent defects are lost |
| 6 | Purchase order | Quantity, price, delivery date, payment milestones, reference to the four documents above | Procurement, within delegated authority | Sales director | A conflicting term with no precedence rule to resolve it |
| 7 | Compliance declarations | Export classification, licence status, end-use and end-user statements, certificate of conformity | Trade compliance lead | Export control officer | Goods are held at export, or arrive that the buyer cannot lawfully place on the market |
| 8 | Logistics, insurance and title terms | Incoterms version, named place, point of title transfer, insurance cover and loss payee | Logistics manager | Export team | Risk and title sit with a party that has no control over the goods |
Three sequencing errors account for most of the disputes that reach lawyers.
The first is the quotation pack. A supplier’s response to a request for quotation usually includes drawings, a process description and sometimes a customer list, and it is sent before any NDA is discussed because the buyer asked for a price. Send a one-page mutual NDA with the request, and if the supplier will not sign one, send a redacted outline that carries the dimensions and the materials but not the tolerances or the process. A supplier that refuses both is telling you how it treats confidential information.
The second is the tooling deposit. Money is paid against a proforma invoice that describes “mould development” in a single line. The tooling schedule, the bailment clause and the title plate should exist before the deposit leaves, because after payment the supplier has the cash and the buyer has an argument.
The third is the quality agreement. It is treated as a document for the quality team to settle during the ramp, while the purchase order is placed to secure a slot. Under the Civil Code the parties may agree inspection periods and acceptance standards, and where they have not, the statutory default applies. A buyer that has not agreed a sampling plan has agreed to whatever the law supplies, which is rarely the regime it wanted.
Each document in the chain should also name its custodian. In a dispute or a customs verification, the party that can produce the signed revision, the tooling schedule and the inspection records within a day wins the point. In most programmes those three documents sit with three different people, none of whom knows the others exist.
Design release: the document set that starts everything
The design package is the most valuable thing the buyer hands over, and it is usually handed over in the least controlled way. Drawings go out by email in response to a quotation request, the supplier marks them up, and the marked-up version becomes the de facto specification because it is the version the factory is working from.
A controlled release has four elements. A frozen revision, identified by number and date, issued as a single package rather than as attachments across a thread. A bill of materials at the level the supplier needs, with approved manufacturers and part numbers where the buyer requires specific components. A test specification that states how conformity is measured, including tolerances, sampling and the conditions of test. And a change control procedure that says who may change what, in which form, with what approval.
For AI hardware the package also carries firmware, model weights where they are embedded in the device, calibration data and test scripts. These are not drawings, and they are often omitted from the technical annex. They should be listed, versioned and treated as confidential information, because firmware is frequently the part of the product that a competitor most wants and the part that a supplier most easily retains after the relationship ends.
Ownership of the design needs an express clause. Under Chinese law, a design commissioned from a supplier does not automatically belong to the buyer; the parties are expected to agree, and where they do not, the statutory default may leave the supplier with rights in the work. The contract should say that all intellectual property in the deliverables, including drawings, tooling designs, test fixtures, process documentation and firmware created for the buyer, vests in the buyer on creation or on payment, with a waiver of moral rights where that is possible and a further assurance obligation where it is not.
Employee inventions are a related trap. Chinese patent law allocates service inventions to the employer, and the employer’s internal reward and remuneration rules matter when an inventor leaves or disputes ownership. A buyer that relies on a supplier’s design should confirm that the supplier has assignment and reward arrangements with its engineers, because a dispute over inventorship inside the supplier can cloud the buyer’s title.
The non-disclosure agreement is necessary and insufficient. Chinese courts enforce confidentiality clauses, but proving breach and quantifying loss is difficult. The agreement works better when it is built around trade secret protection: define confidential information to include drawings, process parameters, firmware, test data and yield data; require return or destruction on termination; restrict copying; and set liquidated damages at a level a court will enforce rather than a symbolic figure.
Operationally, limit what the factory can see. Send drawings in stages, keep critical process parameters with your own engineer, use separate suppliers for critical subassemblies, and mark every document with the owner and the confidentiality level. Where the supplier must share data with subcontractors, require flow-down obligations and a named list of recipients.
Design-for-manufacture feedback is the point at which the buyer learns what the factory will actually struggle to build. It should be a written report against the released revision, not a conversation, and the resulting changes should go through the same change control as any later revision. A programme that accepts verbal DFM changes ends up with a product that matches neither the drawing nor the sample.
Tooling: converting a drawing into an asset
Tooling is where the money leaves the buyer’s account before any saleable product exists, and it is the most litigated asset in Chinese manufacturing relationships. The buyer pays for the mould, the supplier holds it, and when the relationship ends nobody agrees who may take it.
The first decision is funding. The buyer may pay for the tooling outright as a separate line item, the supplier may pay and amortise the cost through the piece price over an agreed volume, or the cost may be shared. Outright purchase is cleanest for ownership, because the invoice and the payment record name the buyer. Amortisation is cheaper in cash but creates ambiguity: the supplier paid the toolmaker, holds the invoice and possesses the tooling, and the buyer’s only evidence is a price schedule that refers to tooling amortisation without saying who owns the asset.
Where amortisation is used, the agreement should state that the tooling is owned by the buyer from the date of first payment, that the supplier holds it on bailment, and that the amortised amount is a contribution to the buyer’s cost rather than a sale of the tooling to the supplier. A schedule of tooling, with serial numbers and replacement values, should be annexed and updated when new tools are added.
The second decision is who builds the tool. In many programmes the supplier does not build it. It instructs a specialist toolmaker, often in the same industrial park, and the toolmaker’s invoice is addressed to the supplier. The buyer then has a chain of title problem: the toolmaker contracted with the supplier, the supplier paid, and the buyer’s only link is the supply agreement. If the supplier becomes insolvent or the relationship fails, the toolmaker may assert rights over the tooling or refuse to release it to anyone other than its customer.
Three documents close that gap. A tripartite acknowledgement among the buyer, the supplier and the toolmaker confirming that the tooling is held for the buyer. A waiver by the toolmaker of any lien over the tooling in favour of the buyer. And, where the amounts justify it, a direct contract between the buyer and the toolmaker for the build, with the supplier acting as technical coordinator.
The third decision is what the contract says about possession. The supplier should hold the tooling as bailee, mark it as the buyer’s property, maintain it to the toolmaker’s schedule, insure it at replacement value with the buyer as loss payee, and permit inspection. On termination, the buyer should have the right to remove or transfer the tooling, with a defined access window and a cooperation obligation.
Lien risk needs to be understood rather than wished away. A manufacturer in lawful possession of a mould may assert a possessory lien for unpaid processing fees, and Chinese law recognises a lien in narrower circumstances than many suppliers assume. The practical protections are to keep payments current, to separate the bailment from the supply contract where possible, and to record title plates on the tool. The strongest protection remains not letting arrears accumulate.
Obsolete tooling needs a decision in advance. Leaving it with the supplier invites use for other customers; requiring destruction needs a certificate and, sometimes, a witness. Either is acceptable. Silence is not, because silence produces a tool that is neither yours in practice nor destroyed.
Finally, tooling is not only moulds. Test fixtures, jigs, programming fixtures, calibration rigs and burn-in racks are tooling for these purposes, and they are the items most often left off the schedule. A fixture that holds the board during test can embody process know-how that the buyer would not want reproduced at a competitor’s plant.
Qualifying the supplier and the part
Supplier qualification has two halves: the company and the part. The company half is due diligence. The part half is technical qualification. Both need documents, and the documents serve different purposes.
Due diligence on a Chinese manufacturer is cheap compared with a failed launch, because the public record is unusually rich.
| Check | Where to look | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Legal existence and scope | Business licence, National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System | Confirms the entity, registered capital and permitted activities |
| Financial substance | Annual reports, paid-in capital, credit information | Registered capital is not paid-in capital |
| Litigation and enforcement | Court judgments, enforcement records, dishonesty list | Reveals payment disputes and asset risk |
| IP position | Patent and trademark records, ownership of designs | Prevents building on a design the supplier does not own |
| Export control history | Supplier declarations, licence records | Flags diversion or restricted end uses |
| Subcontracting | Audit, process map, supplier list | Your product may be made elsewhere |
Repeat the check before each major order. Chinese corporate information changes quickly, and a supplier that looked clean at onboarding can acquire an enforcement record within a year. A trading company that presents itself as a manufacturer is a common finding; the business licence, the factory audit and the address on the environmental permit should all point to the same entity.
The part half of qualification is where engineering and law meet. The buyer should define the specification precisely, including tolerances, test methods and the sampling plan, and should require first-article approval before mass production. The golden sample, signed by both sides and retained by both, is the reference point for every later dispute about whether a unit conforms. Without it, a defect claim becomes an argument about what the specification meant.
The quality agreement is the document that turns the specification into an operating system. It should cover sampling and acceptance criteria, the inspection period and what counts as deemed acceptance, traceability requirements, audit rights, the handling of non-conforming product, the warranty process and the escalation route. It should also require notification before any change to the process, the line, the subcontractor or the material, because most field failures trace back to an unannounced change rather than to a design defect.
Capability and capacity are separate questions. A supplier that can make the part may not be able to make the volume, and a supplier that can make the volume may not be able to hold the tolerance across a shift change. Ask for process capability data, not a sample. Ask for the line loading at the month you intend to ramp. Ask what happens to your allocation when a larger customer raises its forecast.
The approved vendor list belongs in the quality agreement, with a consent right over additions. Where the buyer has designed around a specific component, the approved manufacturers and part numbers belong in the technical annex, because a substitution made to protect a delivery date can change the certification position, the reliability profile and, in some cases, the export classification.
Contract architecture and the order of precedence
Most Chinese manufacturing relationships use a frame agreement plus purchase orders, technical annexes and a quality agreement. The common failure is that these documents conflict and no clause says which prevails.
A workable structure has four layers. The frame agreement covers confidentiality, intellectual property, liability, termination and governing law. The purchase order covers quantity, price, delivery and payment. The technical annex defines specifications, drawings, acceptance criteria and change control. The quality agreement covers sampling, audits, traceability and warranty handling.
Add a clear order of precedence. A typical ranking places the frame agreement above the quality agreement, the quality agreement above the technical annex and the technical annex above the purchase order, with the purchase order prevailing on price and quantity only. Whatever ranking is chosen, the point is that a conflict has a predetermined answer rather than being resolved after a dispute by whoever argues best.
Chinese law governs most of these contracts by default when the supplier, the performance and the assets are in China. Choosing foreign law without a foreign-related element may not be effective, and even where it is effective, Chinese courts may apply mandatory local rules. Governing law, arbitration and enforcement should be chosen together rather than separately. A contract governed by English law but litigated in a Chinese court is a compromise that rarely produces the outcome the drafter imagined; a contract with a Hong Kong or Singapore arbitration clause and a Chinese law governing clause is a common and workable combination, because the award is enforceable under the New York Convention and the tribunal can apply Chinese law with expert evidence.
Formalities matter more than foreign counsel expect. Chinese companies contract under a company chop, and the authority of the person holding it is not always documented. Obtain the business licence, the legal representative’s identity document and, where a nominee signs, a board resolution or power of attorney. Check that the contracting entity is the entity that will invoice and the entity that will export, because a group with a manufacturing company, a trading company and a Hong Kong holding company will often present the trading company’s quotation and the manufacturing company’s capability.
Language is a substantive issue. A bilingual contract should state which version prevails, and the Chinese version should be reviewed by someone who can read it, not merely translated by the supplier. Where the two versions differ on liability or IP, the prevailing language clause decides the dispute before the merits are reached.
Mass production: change control and acceptance
The production phase is where the documents drafted earlier either work or are exposed.
Change control is the first test. An engineering change note should be raised for any change to the design, the material, the process, the line, the subcontractor or the test method. The note should record the reason, the affected part numbers, the validation required, the approval and the effective date. A supplier that changes a solder paste, a supplier of a connector or the location of a test step without notice has changed the product in a way that may affect certification, reliability and, where the item is controlled, its export classification.
Inspection and acceptance are the second test. The Civil Code allows the parties to agree inspection periods and acceptance standards, and silence can work against the buyer. A short inspection period may be treated as acceptance of latent defects the buyer could not see; an unlimited period may be unenforceable or commercially unacceptable. The workable structure is a defined inspection period for visible and measurable defects, plus a warranty period and a separate latent defect clause for defects that could not reasonably have been discovered.
Remedies should be sequenced: repair, replacement, rework, price reduction, then termination. A cap on liability is normal, but the cap should not exclude fraud or wilful misconduct, and consequential loss exclusions need to be checked against the jurisdictions in which the buyer will enforce. Recall and field-failure costs should be allocated expressly, because those are the numbers that decide whether a defect is survivable.
Traceability is the third test. For AI hardware, a unit that fails in the field needs to be traced to a production lot, a test record and a component batch. The quality agreement should specify the serialisation scheme, the retention period for records and the buyer’s right to obtain the records on request. Where the product carries a radio module or a cellular modem, the traceability record also supports certification defence, because a regulator investigating interference will ask which units were built to which configuration.
Subcontracting is the fourth test. The buyer contracted with a factory, and the factory may subcontract the anodising, the cable assembly or the PCBA. Each subcontract adds a party the buyer has not vetted and a location the buyer has not audited. A consent right, a named list and flow-down obligations are the minimum. A process map that shows every site the product touches is better.
Audit rights should be exercisable during production, not only at the end. A buyer that inspects only at shipment inspects a finished good; a buyer that inspects during production can see a process drifting before the yield collapses. The quality agreement should give notice rights for audits, access to the line and the records, and the right to interview the process engineer.
Compliance gates before shipment
Two compliance questions must be answered before the first commercial shipment: whether the item may leave China and reach the buyer, and whether the buyer may place it on the target market.
On the first, China’s Export Control Law, in force since December 2020, and the dual-use items regulations that took effect in December 2024 create licensing requirements for controlled items, software and technology. Controls have been extended to certain critical minerals, including gallium, germanium, graphite, antimony and several rare earth categories. A Chinese supplier may be unable to ship to the buyer, or may ship something the buyer’s own jurisdiction will not let it import.
Foreign controls matter as well. US export administration rules can reach items made outside the United States when they contain controlled US technology or are produced with controlled equipment, and entity-list restrictions affect who may receive certain chips and systems. AI hardware sits at the intersection, so the buyer needs the supplier’s classification and licence position in writing, not an assurance that the product is civil.
Contract for this. Require the supplier to state the classification of the item, confirm licence status, provide end-use and end-user declarations, and notify any change. Include a right to suspend or terminate if a licence is denied, and cooperation on audits. Treat classification as a technical and legal exercise with a named owner, because a supplier’s commercial team will always describe the product as ordinary.
On the second question, certification is market-specific.
| Mark | Market | Nature | Key point |
|---|---|---|---|
| CCC | China | Mandatory for catalogue products | Administered under SAMR; required before sale |
| SRRC type approval | China | Mandatory for radio transmitters | Applies to Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and cellular modules |
| Network access licence | China | Mandatory for telecom terminals | Required for devices connecting to public networks |
| CE | European Union | Self-declaration or notified body | Technical file and declaration of conformity |
| FCC | United States | Supplier declaration or certification | Rules depend on device class and radio type |
A Chinese certificate does not satisfy European or US requirements, and a CE declaration does not authorise Chinese sale. Test reports can sometimes be reused across regimes, but the standards, labelling and responsible-party obligations differ. Build a certification matrix into the project plan, with an owner for each mark and a dependency on the manufacturing site, because certification issued against one factory may need to be reissued if production moves.
The responsible party is the point foreign buyers most often miss. A CE declaration is made by an entity established in the relevant market, and that entity carries obligations that survive the sale. If the Chinese supplier issues the declaration, the buyer may find that the responsible party is a company it cannot reach when a regulator or a customer complains. Decide deliberately whether the importer, the buyer’s local entity or the supplier acts as responsible party, and reflect the choice in the contract.
Labelling is part of the same gate. A device sold in China needs Chinese-language marking and the required certification marks; a device sold in Europe needs the conformity mark, the importer’s name and address and the technical file behind it. Packaging artwork is a specification item, not a print job, and it should be approved through the same change control as the product.
Shipment, title and payment
Incoterms 2020 allocate cost, risk and formalities, but they do not allocate title or regulatory responsibility. That distinction causes more disputes than the terms themselves.
FOB is common in Chinese quotations. It places export clearance on the seller and transfers risk at the ship’s rail, which may not match a container that the buyer expects delivered to its door. DDP makes the seller the importer of record, which can conflict with the buyer’s own certification and product liability position, and which may be unlawful or impractical where the seller has no establishment in the destination market. State the version and the named place precisely, because “FOB Shenzhen” and “FOB Shenzhen, Incoterms 2020” are not the same instruction to a freight forwarder.
Title is separate. Unless the contract says otherwise, title may pass with the documents, or later, or not at all where the supplier retains title until payment. A retention of title clause is common and should be read against the buyer’s need to pledge inventory or to sell goods it has not yet paid for. Where the buyer finances inventory, the lender will want clear title at a defined point.
Payment terms usually combine a deposit, progress payments and retention. Letters of credit, parent guarantees and set-off rights are worth more than a promise, particularly where the supplier is a single factory with limited capital. The structure should match the cash need at each stage: tooling before the tool exists, materials before the line runs, balance on acceptance rather than on shipment, and retention until the warranty period has run a defined distance.
Two administrative points cause disproportionate problems. The first is entity mismatch: the invoice must come from the contracting entity, and the export declaration must name the same entity, or the buyer’s customs file will not reconcile. The second is currency and foreign exchange: the invoicing currency, the payment route and the tax treatment should be confirmed with the finance team before the first order, because a structure that works commercially can fail at the bank.
Where the parties are related, the price must also survive a transfer pricing review. A Chinese manufacturer selling to an offshore affiliate at a price that does not reflect its functions, assets and risks is exposed to an adjustment, and the adjustment can arrive years later. Intercompany agreements, a benchmarking file and consistent invoicing are the defences, and they should be prepared when the structure is set rather than when the tax authority asks.
After-sales: warranty, returns and end of life
The warranty is where the contract’s allocation of risk becomes a monthly cost. A warranty that is generous on paper but unworkable in process produces disputes; a warranty that is narrow but administered well produces predictability.
The mechanism needs four parts. A defined warranty period, starting from a defined event, which should be delivery or first use rather than shipment, because the buyer may hold inventory. A returns process with an RMA number, a diagnostic step, a decision point and a freight allocation. A remedy sequence that matches the supply agreement, so that the supplier cannot choose repair when the buyer needs replacement. And a reporting obligation, because a defect trend is only visible if the supplier sees the field data.
Latent defects need separate treatment. A defect that could not reasonably have been discovered at inspection may surface after the warranty period, and the buyer needs a clause that survives it. The clause should define the standard, allocate the burden of proof and set a longstop date. Without it, the buyer is arguing that a defect was hidden, which is an argument about facts it may not be able to prove.
Recall and field campaigns are the largest contingent exposure. The contract should allocate the cost of a recall caused by a supplier defect, including labour, freight, customer penalties and the cost of the campaign itself, and should require the supplier to cooperate with a recall plan. Insurance is part of the answer, and the buyer should check that its product liability cover extends to goods manufactured in China and to the supplier’s premises.
Spare parts and end-of-life need a clause before the product is discontinued. A last-time-buy right, a defined period of spare-part availability and a transition assistance obligation allow the buyer to plan a replacement product rather than discover that a connector is unavailable. Where tooling is involved, the end of life triggers the tooling schedule: return, transfer or destruction, with a certificate.
Connected devices add a data dimension. If the product sends telemetry to the supplier for diagnostics, the buyer needs a data processing arrangement that covers what is collected, where it is stored and who may access it. A supplier with remote access to devices in the field is processing data on the buyer’s behalf, and in China that engages the personal information and data security regime. The arrangement should be in place before the first device is activated, not after a customer asks where the data goes.
Failure modes
| Failure | Stage | Consequence | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design ownership left to the statutory default | Design release | Supplier claims the design or licences it to a competitor | Express assignment of all deliverables, including firmware and fixtures |
| Tooling paid for but never titled or marked | Tooling | Mould stranded, or held against unpaid invoices | Tooling schedule, bailment clause, title plates, tripartite toolmaker acknowledgement |
| Verbal DFM changes accepted | Design release | Production units match neither drawing nor sample | Written DFM report and change orders against the frozen revision |
| Quality agreement signed after the first order | Qualification | No inspection period, no sampling plan, deemed acceptance disputed | Quality agreement before the purchase order |
| Unannounced process or subcontractor change | Mass production | Yield collapse, certification invalid, defect claims contested | Change notification clause, approved vendor list, audit rights |
| Supplier’s classification taken on trust | Compliance | Shipment held, licence refused, contract silent on who bears the loss | Written classification, end-use declarations, suspension right |
| Certification assumed to travel | Compliance | Product cannot be sold in the target market | Certification matrix per market, with a named responsible party |
| Contracting entity differs from exporter and invoice | Shipment | Customs file does not reconcile, warranty unenforceable | Align contract, invoice, exporter and warranty provider |
| Warranty silent on latent defects and recalls | After-sales | Buyer absorbs field failure and campaign cost | Latent defect clause, recall cost allocation, insurance check |
| No last-time-buy or transition right | End of life | Line stops when a part is discontinued | Last-time-buy, spare-part period, transition assistance |
The pattern across the table is consistent. The failures that cost the most are not the ones caused by a supplier behaving badly. They are the ones caused by a document that was never signed, or was signed by the wrong entity, or was overtaken by a later document with no precedence clause to resolve the conflict.
Practical checklist
- Freeze the design in a single revisioned package, and list firmware, calibration data and test scripts as deliverables.
- Obtain an express assignment of intellectual property in drawings, tooling, fixtures, process documentation and firmware.
- Define the deal shape in writing: OEM, ODM, toll processing or component supply, with the IP and liability consequences that follow.
- Run public-record due diligence and a factory audit before the first purchase order, and repeat before each major order.
- Sign the quality agreement and technical annex before production, with an order of precedence clause.
- Create a tooling schedule, mark your property, record replacement values and provide for return, transfer and lien risk.
- Require written notification of any change to design, material, process, line or subcontractor.
- Obtain the supplier’s export control classification and licence position in writing, with end-use declarations.
- Build a certification matrix for every target market and name the responsible party for each mark.
- Match the Incoterm, payment structure, contracting entity, exporter and warranty provider, and document the after-sales process before the first shipment.
None of this requires a large legal budget at the outset. It requires a decision, taken early, that the documents are part of the product. A buyer that treats the technical annex, the tooling schedule and the quality agreement as engineering deliverables, rather than as paperwork to be completed after the commercial terms are agreed, avoids most of the failures described here.
Geason Law Offices acts for foreign buyers and investors on Chinese manufacturing contracts, supplier due diligence and export control. Our commercial contracts, IP protection and export controls teams can review a supplier pack or draft the full document set before a purchase order is issued. For the related decisions, see Tooling Ownership and Mould IP in China, Incoterms 2020 for China Sourcing and China vs Vietnam for AI Hardware Manufacturing.
Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article
What should we check before signing with a Chinese hardware supplier?
Check the business licence and whether the stated scope covers the work, paid-in capital, litigation and enforcement records, ownership of the supplier's IP, export control history and any reliance on subcontractors. A factory audit and a check of the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System are the minimum, and both should be repeated before each major purchase order.
Who owns the mould or tooling we pay for in China?
Ownership depends on the contract, and the default position is not always favourable to the buyer. State expressly that you own the tooling, mark it, record it in a bailment schedule and provide for return or destruction on termination. Pay attention to lien risk, because a manufacturer in possession of your mould may claim security for unpaid processing fees.
Do Chinese export controls apply to AI hardware sold to us?
Yes. China's Export Control Law and the dual-use items regulations can require a licence for controlled items, software and technology, and controls have been extended to certain critical minerals and rare earths. Ask the supplier for its classification, licence status and end-use declarations, and do not assume a product is uncontrolled because it is sold commercially.
Is CCC certification enough to sell AI hardware in Europe or the US?
No. CCC is a Chinese market access requirement, CE marking is the European route and FCC rules apply in the United States, and each has its own technical standards and documentation. Test reports can sometimes be reused, but the declarations, responsible parties and labelling differ, so plan certification per market rather than assuming one approval travels.
How should we allocate risk under Incoterms?
Choose the term that matches who can actually clear export and import formalities. FOB is common in Chinese quotations but leaves export clearance and loading risk with the seller only up to the ship's rail, while DDP makes the seller the importer of record and may conflict with your certification obligations. State the Incoterms version and the named place precisely.
Who bears the risk if the supplier cannot deliver because of export restrictions?
The answer depends on how the contract defines force majeure, change of law and allocation. A well-drafted clause treats a denied export licence as a defined event, sets notice and mitigation duties, and gives you termination and refund rights. A generic force majeure clause often leaves you waiting and without an alternative source.
Can we rely on the supplier's quality certificate?
A certificate is evidence, not a substitute for your own acceptance regime. Set specifications and sampling methods in an annex, define the inspection period and deemed acceptance rules, and require first-article approval before mass production. Keep the right to audit and to inspect during production, not only at shipment.