An AI project has gone wrong. The model did not meet the accuracy promised in the pilot, the training data turned out to be licensed from a third party, a former engineer joined a competitor with your fine-tuned weights, or your Chinese distributor stopped paying. Where you litigate determines how long the case takes, what evidence you can obtain and whether a win can be collected. Most foreign companies discover these choices too late, after the contract has been signed and the relationship has broken down.
By the time a dispute is real, three decisions have already been taken: the forum, the service address, and what the contract obliges anyone to record. Those three decide more outcomes than the merits do. A good claim heard in the wrong forum produces a judgment that cannot be collected where the assets sit. A thin record in the right forum produces an award that is enforceable and empty.
The conclusion for a foreign AI company is narrower than the general debate about Chinese litigation. For a cross-border contract, arbitration seated outside the mainland, before a precisely named institution, with a contractual service address and evidence-generating obligations, is the combination that most often produces something collectable. Chinese court litigation is the better instrument when the objective is to freeze a bank account, stop a product launch or preserve a server before the other side can act. This guide works through both, then maps forum and evidence onto the disputes AI companies actually bring.
Who this guide is for
- Foreign companies with Chinese licensing, development, distribution or supply contracts that are heading toward a dispute.
- In-house counsel deciding between court and arbitration in a China-facing agreement.
- Investors and boards assessing recovery options after a portfolio company fails in China.
Stage: Execute. Use this once a dispute is likely or already underway, and before you sign the next China contract. The drafting sections are not background reading; they are the part of the article that still has value after the first dispute has been resolved.
The disputes that actually arise
| Dispute type | Typical claim | Usual forum | Practical note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract performance | Delay, shortfall, refusal to deliver | Court or arbitration per clause | The clause decides, not the parties’ preference after the event |
| Service quality | Model accuracy below specification | Court or arbitration | Depends on measurable acceptance criteria |
| IP and model ownership | Ownership, licence breach, plagiarism | Court, IP tribunal | Registration and assignment documents are decisive |
| Trade secret and unfair competition | Misappropriation of weights or data | Court | Evidence preservation is critical |
| Product liability | Harm caused by an AI-enabled device | Court | Technical appraisal usually required |
| Distribution and agency | Termination, commissions, territory | Court | Local rules protect distributors in some cases |
| Labour and poaching | Breach of non-compete or confidentiality | Labour arbitration, then court | Labour arbitration is a mandatory first step |
The table is not a taxonomy. Each row carries a different forum default, a different centre of evidential gravity and a different enforcement profile, and the label a claimant chooses changes all three. The same facts — an engineer who left with fine-tuned weights — can be pleaded as breach of a confidentiality clause, as misappropriation of a trade secret, or as infringement of software copyright in the training pipeline. The first is a contract claim heard in a commercial division. The second is an unfair competition claim in which evidence preservation is the whole case. The third may be heard by a specialised intellectual property tribunal with technical judges and its own case-management practice. Pleading all three in the alternative looks thorough and usually forfeits the procedural advantage of each.
A second pattern recurs across the table: the claim that is easiest to prove is rarely the claim that recovers the most. A supplier can prove an unpaid invoice with a contract, a delivery note and a tax invoice, and recover the price. The loss that matters commercially — a distributor’s diversion of customers, a licensee’s use of the model to train a rival — requires documents the supplier does not hold. That gap is a drafting problem, not a litigation problem, and it is why the evidence sections below sit alongside the forum analysis rather than after it.
Courts: levels, jurisdiction and foreign-related cases
China has four court levels: basic people’s courts, intermediate courts, high courts and the Supreme People’s Court. Most first-instance commercial cases start in a basic court, with intermediate courts handling larger or more sensitive matters and specialised intellectual property cases. The monetary thresholds that determine which level hears a case vary by province and are adjusted periodically, so they must be checked at filing rather than assumed.
For foreign-related cases, the analysis is different. The 2023 amendments to the Civil Procedure Law, effective from 2024, expanded the circumstances in which Chinese courts may take jurisdiction, including where the dispute has an appropriate connection with China. Some categories, such as certain disputes over Sino-foreign joint ventures, are subject to exclusive jurisdiction. The practical consequence is that a Chinese court may accept a case even where your contract names a foreign court, and parallel proceedings in two countries are possible.
Jurisdiction clauses therefore need to be drafted for China, not copied from a US or UK template. Confirm that the chosen court has jurisdiction under Chinese rules, that the clause is not so vague as to be unenforceable, and that service on a foreign party can be effected in a way the court will accept.
Three features of the Chinese rules catch drafters. An agreed court must have a genuine connection to the dispute — the defendant’s domicile, the place of performance, the place of signature, the plaintiff’s domicile or the location of the subject matter — so a clause naming a neutral court with no link to the transaction may simply fail. The agreement cannot displace the rules on level jurisdiction, which means the parties cannot send a small claim to a high court by agreement. And an agreement cannot displace exclusive jurisdiction, which is why a clause choosing a foreign court in a Sino-foreign joint venture contract is worth very little when the dispute concerns the joint venture itself.
There is a further asymmetry that foreign counsel often miss. A Chinese court may accept jurisdiction where the defendant is domiciled in China even where the contract names a foreign court, particularly where the chosen court declines the case or has no real connection with the dispute. The clause matters most when the defendant has no Chinese presence and you want the case heard somewhere else. If the defendant is a Chinese company with Chinese assets, assume a Chinese court is available to it whether or not it is available to you.
The definition of “foreign-related” is itself a drafting question. It affects which procedural privileges apply — longer appeal periods, different service rules, the ability to choose foreign law — and it affects whether a choice of foreign law will be respected at all. A contract between two Chinese entities for a project in China is not foreign-related merely because it is written in English or performed with imported equipment. Where the foreign element is thin, Chinese law may apply regardless of the governing law clause.
Arbitration or litigation
| Feature | Chinese court | Arbitration (CIETAC, SHIAC, SCIA) | Offshore arbitration (HKIAC) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cross-border enforcement | Limited, treaty or reciprocity | New York Convention | New York Convention plus Hong Kong arrangement |
| Timeline | Statutory limits, but crowded dockets | Usually faster to hearing, depends on tribunal | Flexible, often preferred by foreign parties |
| Confidentiality | Public hearings and published judgments | Confidential by default | Confidential |
| Interim relief | Court can preserve assets and evidence | Institution forwards application to court | Tribunal and Hong Kong court support |
| Appeals | Full appeal on law and fact | Very limited set-aside grounds | Very limited set-aside grounds |
| Cost | Lower court fees | Institution and tribunal fees | Usually highest |
Arbitration is generally the better default for cross-border AI contracts because the award travels. Litigation can be preferable where you need urgent preservation, where the counterparty’s assets are all in mainland China, or where the dispute turns on a point of Chinese public policy.
If you choose arbitration, name the institution precisely. Clauses referring to a city rather than an institution, or naming two institutions, are a common source of jurisdiction fights. China does not generally recognise ad hoc arbitration for domestic disputes, and an unclear clause can invalidate the whole agreement to arbitrate.
The scope wording deserves as much attention as the institution. “All disputes arising out of or in connection with this Agreement” captures tort claims that arise from the relationship, including misappropriation of confidential information and interference with the contract. “All disputes arising under this Agreement” is narrower, and a defendant who wants to litigate a trade secret claim in court will argue that the claim arises outside the contract. Where the counterparty is a Chinese company with assets in China, that argument buys it a change of forum at the moment you least want one.
Two structural choices also repay thought. A multi-tier clause requiring negotiation or mediation before arbitration is enforceable in some seats and treated as unenforceable in others; if you include one, define the trigger, the period and what happens if the period expires, and do not make the arbitration conditional on a process with no end date. And a clause that gives one party a unilateral choice between two institutions, or between arbitration and litigation, is a clause that will be litigated rather than used.
A forum and evidence map, dispute by dispute
The sections below take each dispute type and set out where it is heard, what decides it and what to do in the first fortnight. The first fortnight matters because preservation, service and the choice of claim are all fixed early, and none of them can be repaired later.
Failure to deliver, late delivery and non-payment
These are the ordinary commercial claims, and they are decided by documents that either exist or do not. The forum follows the clause. A Chinese court will hear a claim against a Chinese supplier quickly and cheaply; a foreign-seat tribunal will hear it slowly and expensively but produce an award that can be enforced against the supplier’s overseas assets, which a Chinese judgment generally cannot.
What decides the case is a chain: the contract and its appendices, the purchase orders, the delivery notes signed and stamped at the factory gate, the acceptance record, the tax invoices and the bank records. Chinese practice attaches weight to documents bearing a company seal, and a delivery note signed by an unnamed warehouse employee is worth less than one signed by a person whose authority can be shown. Where the parties have traded for years on purchase orders and invoices with no master agreement, the court will reconstruct the terms from the course of dealing, and the party with the tidier file usually wins.
The first move is to secure the paper. Request the complete transaction file from your own team, including the WeChat correspondence in which quantities and dates were agreed, and have it exported with metadata rather than screenshotted. Where the counterparty is likely to deny receipt, apply for evidence preservation early rather than at the hearing.
Model quality and acceptance
A claim that a model underperformed is a claim about a benchmark, and a benchmark is only as good as the clause that defines it. The forum is whichever the clause provides, but the case will turn on the acceptance procedure: the dataset used, the metric, the threshold, the number of runs, who tests and what happens on a marginal result.
Courts and tribunals are comfortable with a failed acceptance test and uncomfortable with a general allegation of poor performance. Where the contract says the model must achieve a stated accuracy on a stated dataset and the test was run as specified, the claim is close to documentary. Where the contract says the model must be “fit for purpose” or “state of the art”, the case becomes an expert dispute in which each side produces a report and the decision-maker chooses between methodologies it does not fully understand.
The evidence to assemble is the acceptance protocol, the test logs with timestamps and model versions, the dataset version actually used, and the correspondence in which the parties agreed or disputed the result. If the customer ran its own tests after go-live, those results are useful only if the environment and the data can be shown to be comparable. The trap is a pilot that succeeded on curated data and a production failure on real data: the contract needs to say which data governs acceptance, or the supplier will argue the model met the specification and the customer will argue the specification was irrelevant.
Ownership of the model, the code and the output
Ownership disputes are heard by courts with intellectual property jurisdiction. In China that means a basic court with designated IP jurisdiction for smaller matters, an intermediate court for larger ones, and, for technical cases, the specialised intellectual property courts in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou or the Supreme People’s Court’s intellectual property tribunal on final review. The technical composition of the panel is a real advantage in a case about model architecture and a real disadvantage if your case is really about an unpaid invoice dressed as an IP claim.
What decides ownership is the assignment, not the invoice. Chinese law starts from a default that surprises foreign customers: where work is commissioned and the contract is silent, rights in the deliverable can sit with the party that created it. Registration is evidence rather than title — software copyright registration creates a presumption that can be displaced — but the party holding the registration certificate starts ahead. Where the dispute concerns weights and parameters rather than code, the case is usually pleaded as a trade secret claim because there is no registration to point to.
The first move is a document audit: the development agreement, any statement of work that varies it, the assignment language, the list of third-party and open-source components, and the record of what was delivered. Where the assignment is missing, the claim becomes one for breach of an implied licence or for unjust enrichment, and the value falls.
Trade secrets and departed staff
This is the dispute in which procedure decides the outcome. The forum is a Chinese court, and the claimant’s advantage lasts only as long as the defendant does not know a claim is coming. Evidence preservation of the former employee’s devices, the new employer’s servers and the repository access logs is the case. Once the devices are wiped, the claim is a story.
Two routes run in parallel. The civil route is a claim for misappropriation of trade secrets, with preservation, an application for the court to investigate, and a damages claim that is difficult to quantify. The criminal route, where the loss or the conduct meets the threshold, gives the police powers of search and seizure that no civil court can match, and it changes the negotiation immediately. The two are not exclusive, but they require different evidence and different timing, and a premature civil filing can destroy the element of surprise that the criminal route depends on.
The evidence that matters is unglamorous: the access logs, the download records, the badge records, the exit interview, the confidentiality and non-compete documents, and evidence that the information was treated as secret — access controls, marking, need-to-know restrictions. A trade secret that was available to the whole engineering team without restriction is hard to describe as secret, whatever the contract says.
Product liability and safety incidents
Where an AI-enabled device injures a person or damages property, the claim is heard in a Chinese court, usually where the injury occurred or the defendant is domiciled. The injured party can proceed against the producer or the seller, and the defendant that pays may have a recourse claim up the chain. The case is decided by a technical appraisal, and the appraisal is decided by what was preserved at the scene.
The evidential priorities are the device, its logs, the firmware version, the incident report and the maintenance history. In an AI-enabled product the log may be the only record of what the model decided and why, and it may sit on a server outside China, which creates a conflict between the litigation need to produce it and the data rules that govern taking it out. A supplier that has not planned for that conflict will be asked for evidence it cannot lawfully export.
Distribution, agency and channel termination
These claims are heard in court, and they are covered in detail in the guide to terminating a Chinese distributor. For present purposes, the forum point is that a termination dispute is a money claim, and the money is usually in China. A Chinese court is the cheaper and faster route to a Chinese distributor’s bank account; arbitration buys confidentiality, which matters where pricing and conduct will be examined.
Employment, non-compete and poaching
Labour disputes go to labour arbitration first, and the court only hears the case on appeal from the award. The limitation period is short, and the practical consequence is that a company which discovers a breach months after the event may find the claim time-barred before it has assembled the evidence. Non-compete obligations are enforceable only within limits — a defined group of employees, a defined period, and compensation paid during the restriction — and a clause that imposes a restriction without payment is likely to fail.
Where the target is the new employer rather than the employee, the claim is not a labour claim at all: it is a trade secret or unfair competition claim in the civil courts. Choosing the wrong route wastes the limitation period.
Data incidents and cross-border transfers
An incident that involves personal information engages the cybersecurity and data authorities as well as any private claim. The administrative route runs through reporting obligations, investigations and penalties; the private route runs through contract and tort claims by affected parties, which are harder to bring and harder to value. The evidence that matters is the incident log, the processing records, the transfer assessment or filing that permitted the data flow, and the contractual allocation of responsibility between controller and processor.
The forum question is complicated by the regulator. A private claim filed while an investigation is open will be read against the regulator’s findings, and a public penalty decision becomes the anchor for any follow-on civil claim.
Shareholder and joint venture control
Disputes between shareholders of a Chinese company — deadlock, dilution, removal of a director, control of the seal and the bank accounts — are heard in court, and certain joint venture disputes fall within exclusive jurisdiction. These cases move fast at the start because the remedy is often preservation: freeze the account, preserve the seal, restrain the transfer of equity. The evidence is the constitutional documents, the shareholders’ agreement, the board minutes and the company’s registration file.
The trap for a foreign minority holder is that the documents that prove control are held by the party that controls the company. Preservation applications have to be prepared before the other side realises the relationship has failed, which in practice means before the board meeting at which the relationship fails.
Evidence: what a Chinese court will accept, and how to obtain it
Chinese civil procedure has no US-style discovery. You cannot compel the other side to hand over its code or logs by letter. What you can do is apply for evidence preservation, ask the court to investigate, and rely on contractual rights that create the evidence in the first place.
Electronic data is admissible, and courts assess authenticity by reference to the generation, storage, transmission and extraction process. Practical steps include notarised capture of web pages and app behaviour, trusted timestamping, hash values, forensic imaging of devices, and platform logs with complete metadata. Chinese internet courts have developed blockchain-based evidence platforms, and their approach has influenced practice elsewhere, but a technical report still needs to explain what it proves.
The categories of evidence that carry weight in a Chinese commercial case are narrower than the categories a common-law lawyer expects. Signed and sealed contracts, delivery notes with a company seal, bank records, tax invoices and official registration documents do most of the work. Email is accepted but is easy to dispute; WeChat records are accepted and are now routine, provided the identity of the account holder can be tied to the individual, which usually requires the platform record or an admission. Witness statements carry less weight than in England or the United States, because the witness rarely appears for cross-examination in the way a common-law court expects, and a written statement from an employee of the claimant is treated as a party document.
Algorithmic disputes are harder. The party that controls the model usually controls the evidence, and courts are reluctant to order disclosure of source code without protection for trade secrets. Workable strategies include:
- Agreeing benchmark datasets, acceptance metrics and audit rights before the project starts.
- Requiring versioned model cards, change logs and incident reports as contractual deliverables.
- Applying for evidence preservation at the start of the case, before the other side can change systems.
- Seeking judicial appraisal by a qualified institution on specific technical questions.
- Asking the court to draw adverse inferences where the controlling party refuses to cooperate.
Judicial appraisal in AI cases is expensive and slow, and appraisers may lack domain expertise. The contract is therefore the best evidence-management tool you have.
Three formalities decide whether good evidence is usable. Foreign-language documents must be accompanied by a Chinese translation, and the translation is the version the court reads, so a loose translation of a technical specification can change the case. Documents executed abroad generally need notarisation and, depending on the counterparty state, an apostille or consular legalisation; China has been a party to the Apostille Convention since 2023, which has simplified the route for public documents from member states, but the court’s requirements should be confirmed before filing rather than after. And a power of attorney from a foreign company must be executed with the same formalities and translated, or the lawyer cannot act.
Retention is the quiet part of evidence management. The limitation period for contractual claims is three years, and a dispute can surface years after the relationship ended. A company that deletes project correspondence on a twelve-month cycle, or that loses access to a departed employee’s mailbox, will be explaining the gap rather than the facts.
Interim measures
Chinese courts can order asset preservation, evidence preservation and behaviour preservation. Behaviour preservation is the closest equivalent to an injunction and is common in intellectual property and unfair competition cases, where the court may order a party to stop a launch, a sale or a disclosure while the case proceeds.
Applications are usually decided quickly but require a security deposit, typically a proportion of the amount claimed or a sum set by the court, and evidence of urgency. If you are in arbitration, the institution forwards the application to the competent court; the tribunal itself cannot freeze assets in mainland China.
Timing matters. Preservation is most effective before the other side knows a dispute exists. Preparing the application, the evidence and the security in advance is often more valuable than the legal merits.
Three practical points are worth adding. Asset preservation is only as good as the asset identification: a bank account number, a property registration reference or a shareholding record turns an application into an order, and a general request to freeze “the respondent’s assets” does not. Security can usually be provided as a guarantee from an insurer or a bank rather than cash, which matters where the claimant cannot immobilise its own working capital. And an applicant whose preservation was wrong can be ordered to compensate the respondent for its loss, which is why the urgency evidence should be documented at the time rather than reconstructed afterwards.
Cross-border enforcement
China has been a party to the New York Convention since 1987, with commercial and reciprocity reservations. Arbitral awards from other member states are generally enforceable, subject to the convention’s grounds for refusal, and the Supreme People’s Court has centralised review of refusals to enforce foreign awards to improve consistency.
Hong Kong awards benefit from a separate arrangement between the mainland and Hong Kong, which has been supplemented to cover additional categories of relief. This is one reason HKIAC is often chosen for China-related contracts.
Foreign court judgments are different. China has no broad multilateral judgments convention in force, enforcement depends on bilateral treaties or reciprocity, and practice varies by court. The Supreme People’s Court has encouraged a more open approach to reciprocity, and the China International Commercial Court handles certain international commercial cases, but the route remains less predictable than arbitration.
Inside China, enforcement is a separate proceeding with its own tools. The court can query bank, property, vehicle and securities records, freeze and deduct balances, restrict high-value spending by the debtor’s legal representative, and place the debtor on the list of dishonest judgment debtors, which affects its ability to obtain credit and to bid for government work. Those tools work against a company that intends to keep trading. They work poorly against a company that has moved its assets, which is why the asset investigation should begin before the claim is filed, not after the judgment.
Documents, filings and timeline
| Step | Authority | Typical timing | What foreign companies miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evidence preservation before filing | Basic or intermediate court | Days, if the application is ready | The application needs specific asset or evidence identifiers and security; a general request fails |
| Filing and acceptance | Court with jurisdiction | Decision on acceptance within about a week | A foreign claimant needs a notarised, translated power of attorney before the lawyer can file |
| Court fee | Court | On acceptance | Fees are charged on a sliding scale and are modest; legal costs are not fully recoverable |
| Service on the foreign party | Court, often via the Hague channels | Months where the defendant is abroad | A contractual service address avoids most of the delay |
| Jurisdiction challenge | Court | Early, before the substantive hearing | A vague clause invites a challenge that consumes a year |
| Evidence exchange and appraisal | Court, appraisal institution | Months; appraisal is the long pole | Appraisal requires a defined technical question and a fund for the fee |
| Hearing and judgment | Court | Statutory period runs from acceptance but extensions are routine | Judgments are published, which clients often do not expect |
| Appeal | Intermediate or higher court | 15 days to appeal, 30 in foreign-related cases | The appeal is a full rehearing on fact and law, not a review for error |
| Enforcement | Enforcement division of the court | Months | Enforcement follows assets; a judgment against a shell is a document |
| Recognition of a foreign award | Intermediate court | Months | Refusal decisions go to the Supreme People’s Court for review, which adds time |
Drafting the clause and the errors that follow it
A workable clause answers seven questions: which law governs, which forum hears the dispute, where the arbitration is seated, how many arbitrators, what language, how the parties will serve documents, and whether there is a step before formal proceedings such as expert determination or mediation.
Two China-specific points deserve attention. First, a choice of foreign law may not be effective where the dispute has no foreign-related element, in which case Chinese law applies regardless. Second, service addresses and contact details in the contract are enforceable in Chinese litigation, and a foreign party that omits them risks delays through diplomatic service.
The service clause is the cheapest insurance in the contract and the one most often omitted. It should name an address, an email, a recipient and a consequence: service at that address is effective whether or not the party still occupies it, and a change of address must be notified within a stated period. Courts in China accept contractual service addresses in commercial cases, and the clause converts a diplomatic service route measured in months into a letter.
Five misconceptions cost foreign companies real money.
“We can sue at home and enforce the judgment in China.” Usually not. Judgments travel poorly, and a home-court judgment against a Chinese company is often the start of a second case rather than the end of the first.
“Discovery will get us the model.” There is no discovery, and trade secret protection limits disclosure even where the court orders production. The information you need has to be created by the contract or preserved by an application.
“Arbitration is always faster.” Institution and tribunal availability can add months, and a foreign-seated arbitration adds a recognition step in China. Speed comes from a well-drafted clause and a small tribunal, not from the word “arbitration”.
“A Chinese subsidiary’s signature binds the parent.” Companies are separate legal persons. A parent guarantee needs its own document, its own corporate approval and, where the guarantor is Chinese, a shareholders’ or board resolution that the lender or supplier should see.
“We can submit English documents.” Foreign-language evidence needs translation, which costs time and money, and the translation is what the court reads.
A sixth error sits behind several of these: treating the dispute clause as boilerplate to be settled at the end of a negotiation. It is usually settled in the last hour, by people who want to close, and it is the clause that determines whether the closing was worth it.
Cost and commercial impact
The cost of a Chinese commercial case is dominated by items that are not the court fee. Court fees for a monetary claim are charged on a sliding scale that falls as the amount rises, and they are low by international standards. Arbitration fees are higher and are usually charged by reference to the amount in dispute. Neither is the main line.
The main lines are legal fees, which are not fully recoverable even for the winner; translation and notarisation, which scale with the document set; appraisal, which can exceed the fees of the lawyers; security for preservation, which immobilises cash or requires a guarantee; and time. A first-instance case with a foreign party and a technical appraisal routinely runs past a year, and an appeal adds most of another.
The commercial cost is larger than the legal cost. Management attention is consumed, the counterparty’s customers learn of the dispute, and the relationship that might have been salvageable is not. That is the argument for a settlement architecture in the contract — a defined escalation, a mediation step, an expert determination for technical questions — provided the architecture has an end date.
Practical checklist
- Review every China contract for the governing law, forum and service address clauses.
- Choose arbitration for cross-border deals unless urgent preservation or local assets point to court.
- Name the arbitral institution precisely and specify the seat, language and number of arbitrators.
- Build evidence-generating obligations into the contract: audit rights, logs, model cards and acceptance tests.
- Prepare preservation applications and security before filing, not after the other side reacts.
- Preserve your own records in a forensically sound way, including metadata and version history.
- Check where the counterparty’s assets are before choosing a forum, because enforcement follows assets.
- Budget for translation, notarisation and local counsel from the outset.
- Identify the claim label that carries the best procedural advantage, and plead it first rather than last.
- Fix the limitation date in the file, and diarise it, because three years passes faster than a relationship ends.
Our commercial dispute team handles Chinese litigation, arbitration and enforcement for foreign companies, and the working-with-China disputes section sets out the wider framework. Two related guides are worth reading next: Arbitration or Chinese Courts? Drafting the Dispute Clause and Terminating a Chinese Distributor. Companies that have not yet signed the contract will find more value in AI Commercial Contracts in China than in anything that follows a breach.
This article reflects the position as of late 2026. Procedural rules and judicial practice continue to change, so confirm the current position with Chinese counsel before filing or defending a claim.
Frequently Asked Questions↑ Back to article
Can a foreign company sue in a Chinese court?
Yes. A foreign company can sue in a Chinese court where the court has jurisdiction, for example because the defendant is domiciled in China or the contract is performed there. The case is treated as foreign-related, which affects jurisdiction rules, service, evidence formalities and the time needed, and you will normally need a Chinese litigation agent.
Should we choose arbitration or litigation in a China contract?
Arbitration is usually better for cross-border deals because awards are enforceable in most major jurisdictions under the New York Convention, while Chinese court judgments are harder to enforce abroad. Litigation can be faster and cheaper for purely domestic disputes, and Chinese courts have broader powers to preserve evidence and assets before a claim is heard.
Is CIETAC arbitration enforceable outside China?
Yes, in principle. China is a party to the New York Convention, and CIETAC awards are enforced by courts in other member states, subject to the convention's grounds for refusal. Enforcement still depends on locating assets and on the local court's procedure, so check the target jurisdiction before choosing the seat.
How do you prove what an AI model did?
You build the record before the dispute: versioned logs, acceptance test results, agreed benchmark datasets and audit rights in the contract. In litigation you can seek evidence preservation, court investigation and expert appraisal, and where the other side controls the model, the court may draw adverse inferences if it refuses to cooperate.
Do Chinese courts order document production like US discovery?
No. There is no general discovery obligation, and a party cannot demand the other side's documents at will. You can apply for evidence preservation, ask the court to investigate, or rely on contractual audit and reporting rights, which is why the contract should create the information flow you will need in a dispute.
Will a foreign court judgment be enforced in China?
Only in limited circumstances. China has no broad multilateral judgments treaty, enforcement depends on bilateral treaties or reciprocity, and practice varies between courts. A foreign arbitral award is generally a better route, which is why many cross-border contracts choose arbitration seated outside the mainland.
What interim relief is available before a judgment?
Chinese courts can order asset preservation, evidence preservation and behaviour preservation, which can function like an injunction in intellectual property and unfair competition cases. Applications usually require a security deposit and a showing of urgency, and in arbitration the application is forwarded to the court by the institution.